All the Islanders who are rumoured to be coming back for Love Island: All Stars

Love Island: All Stars is confirmed, and already there’s a hot list of rumoured iconic Islanders who could be returning to join the new cast. The show is back from January 15th, and it looks like it’ll be full of drama.

The names thought to be in consideration for the show include some of the previous series’ biggest icons, OG Islanders and chaotic bombshells, as well as a previous winner who might be back to reclaim their crown. There have also been talks of the possibility of bringing back two Islanders who have split since the show, just to stir the pot.

Honestly, it looks very drama-centric. Here are all the names of rumoured Islanders for the cast of Love Island: All Stars.

Faye Winter

2021 legend Faye Winter has apparently been in “advanced talks” with ITV about her coming back for the All Stars show. According to reports, Faye is now looking to “re-establish” herself as a TV personality, so is eyeing up a second go on the show.

A source told The Sun: “Faye might have hit the headlines during her season of Love Island for all the wrong reasons but since then she’s proven herself to be a kind, genuine woman with a heart of gold. It’s become clear her outbursts in the villa came from insecurity and fear due to past hurt.

“She’s a Love Island legend with tons of fans so really deserves a place in the All Stars villa – it’s a great chance for her to show the public how far she has come. No one has been officially confirmed for Love Island All Stars yet but Faye is in advanced talks.”

Olivia Hawkins

Olivia Hawkins, who was first on the winter 2023 series, has reportedly been “lined-up” by ITV for All Stars. After she had huge beef with Zara on her show, bosses apparently want her back to cause havoc again.

A show source told The Sun: “Liv has had a series of meetings with Love Island bosses and they’re really keen to get her in the All Stars villa. She was the most memorable and talked-about contestant on winter Love Island earlier this year, so they know she won’t be afraid to ruffle feathers and cause drama.

“Final contracts haven’t been signed yet as the cast won’t officially be set in stone until early January, but Liv is looking like one of the red hot favourites to be in there.”

Michael Griffiths

Michael was on Love Island 2019, and was coupled up with Amber Gill before leaving with Joanna Chimonides. They split, so is he on the look for love again?

Megan Barton-Hanson

According to multiple reports, 2018 queen Megan Barton-Hanson is “believed to be taking part” in Love Island: All Stars, so is one of the rumoured Islanders with some pretty good substance behind the whispers.

Earlier this year it was reported Megan had rekindled her romance with ex James Locke, but then she went on Love Island Ganes, so maybe she’s trying to find love again!

Georgia Steel

If there’s one thing we can rely on Georgia Steel being, it’s loyal. And loyal to Love Island she apparently is. Georgia is another Islander who is “believed to be taking part” in the All Stars version, after not finding love on Love Island 2018 and taking part in Love Island Games this year.

Mitch Taylor

Messy Mitch is back! It’s been reported that ITV has “lined up” Mitch to make an epic return to the villa, after splitting from Ella Barnes who he left the show earlier this year with. Coming back and doing it all again is so on brand for him.

Kem Cetinay

The next top contender to make a return is 2017 winner, Kem Cetinay. It’s previously been reported Kem, who broke up with Amber Davies after the show, has been in talks with ITV about the All Stars show. Imagine a winner going back to try again! Watch this space.

Scott van-der-Sluis

He’s back again! Scott was literally only introduced to villa life a few months ago, but already he’s done the UK show, USA Love Island and The Games back-to-back. He didn’t find love any of these times, and because of his seemingly desperate attempts to keep doing the circuit, many think he’ll be back to do the quadruple.

Theo Campbell

Theo was first on Love Island 2017, and was famed for his iconic one-liners, and having a huge stand-off with Jonny Mitchell. After the show, Theo dated 2018 Islander Kaz Crossley, but they split up after 11 months.

In February 2021, Theo revealed he’d become a father for the first time after welcoming a son with influencer Sapphire Yhnell. He’s believed to be single now, though.

Jack Fowler

Jack was on Love Island 2018, but ultimately didn’t find love. In June 2021, he split from girlfriend Joanne Baban Morales after a year together. He was recently revealed to have been mates with 2023 Islander Zachariah Noble, so maybe seeing his mate in the villa has given him a taste for coming back?

Liberty Poole

In an interview with Radio Times, Love Island 2021 star Liberty said she would definitely be keen to go back on the show. Speaking of a possible return for the All Stars Love Island, she said: “I actually would go into an All Stars to be fair. Obviously, it’s a new villa, so it might have been even more weird if it was the villa from last year. But yeah, I would love to go back. I wish I was back for sure.”

Toby Aromolaran

Toby was on Love Island 2021 and left with Chloe Burrows, but the couple later split. Speaking on an episode of his podcast Fancy A Chat? alongside fellow Islander Faye Winter, Toby said he would be willing to go back on the show to “find love” once again. Listen to him Love Island producers, listen!

Chloe Burrows

Among the bookies’ favourites to return is Toby’s ex Chloe, which could be really awkward. It has been previously reported that in a twist ITV might have a couple who have previously broken up both in the villa alongside each other, so Chloe and Toby could be set up to fit that bill.

Chloe is currently on the latest season of Celebs Go Dating, so is clearly very much still in her reality TV and dating on-screen era. According to Betfair, Chloe is the number one favourite previous Islander to return for the new series.

Ellie Brown

Also a bookies’ fav to make a comeback is 2018 star, Ellie Brown. She left the show with millionaire heir Charlie Brake, and had a dramatic breakup which ended in huge fights and a rocky Christmas reunion episode. Betfair has set odds of her return at 18/1.

Ovie Soko

He’s definitely too cool to come back, but a name being thrown around is 2019 icon Ovie Soko. I don’t think the world would be ready if he casually rocked into the South Africa villa, but we can dream!

For the latest Love Island: All Stars news, and for updates, memes and gossip – like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook. 

Related stories recommended by this writer:

• A start date, villa and rumoured Islanders: What we know about Love Island All Stars

• One month on, this is what the Love Island 2023 cast are all up to now

• DMs from footballers and dating each other: What the Casa Amor 2023 Islanders are up to now