Paul reveals which MAFS Australia bride he finds the most attractive, and it’s not Rhi

MAFS Australia has now finished airing down under, and the entire cast has been spilling some major tea about each other after the reunion.

From Beth revealing who she trusts the least to Carina saying which cast member she would block right now, they’re really not holding back.

All of this was part of a Daily Mail Australia game called The Honesty Box, where they had to pull a random question out, and Paul got the juiciest one of all.

“Name the person you found most attractive that wasn’t your match,” his paper said, and guess what his answer was… Katie!

“I seriously think that the most attractive person apart from my match was actually Katie. You deserved everything and you should have stayed there a lot longer,” he said.

@dailymailau

Honesty is the best policy 🤝 #mafs #mafsaustralia #mafsau #dailymail #fyp #australia #realitytv @MAFSGOSSIP

♬ original sound – Daily Mail Australia

When the groom did the photo ranking challenge, Paul put Carina at the top, followed by Rhi, then Jacqui and Awhina.

He didn’t even put Katie in the top five, so I don’t think his answer was very truthful. It was nice for him to give Katie some love though, because she definitely deserved better.

The 37-year-old was the first to leave after her husband Tim put zero effort into their marriage at all and refused to move into the apartments after their honeymoon.

Even on their wedding day, he wouldn’t give her a chance and shockingly asked the producers if there was anyone else to marry, because she wasn’t who he asked for.

Queen Katie left with her head held high though, and she definitely didn’t need MAFS because she’s started a new career venture after the show.

Credit: Nine

Most Read

Lily Phillips reveals how she copes when unattractive men show up to sleep with her

Lily Phillips details harsh truth of her ‘backdoor’ stunt, and the strict rules she had in place

A deep dive into how rich Clint from MAFS Australia 2025 is, plus what his job really is

“Walking back into the Married at First Sight reunion felt like a full-circle moment. Sometimes life knocks the wind out of you, and it takes a little while to get back up and dust yourself off – but the more you do it, the stronger and more resilient you become,” she wrote on Instagram after the reunion.

“I didn’t find the love of my life on this experiment, and things didn’t turn out the way I hoped. But I’ve got no regrets. I faced the worst-case scenario – and learned it’s not as scary as we think. I tested myself beyond what I thought I was capable of, and that’s something I’m proud of.”

“Fresh starts are beautiful. So if you’ve been knocked down, I’m cheering you on as you get back up. Focus on self-love, back yourself, and keep moving forward.”

For all the latest MAFS news, scandals, gossip and updates – like The Holy Church of MAFS on Facebook. 

Featured image by: Nine