Controversial comments are congenial, but Rosie Brown implores you to hold back on the bitching.
It’s no secret that us Cambridge folk enjoy a good debate, a controversial opinion, reacting to anything we disagree with and, as one Tab theatre editor said, ‘creating an inadvertent shitstorm’.
But where do we draw the line in the case of reviews, which unlike abstract or light-hearted articles about weed smokers, actually involve personally critiquing someone’s work, most likely even someone familiar or that we’re actually acquainted with?
I think there’s no question about whether or not the regular theatre-goer, or indeed the average Joe can go ahead and comment. Comments are great. Comments are good. Comment comment comment. They arouse debate, they stimulate alternate opinions, and they are sometimes genuinely useful.
Like the Tab comments section, but not as fun
The real debate lies in whether it is ‘right’ or ‘appropriate’ to respond to a review in the comment section, or anywhere really, if one is involved in the production in some way; whether that be as an actor, director, writer or production team member. I refer in particular to those reviews which are negative, or which single out a particular element of the show or an actor as being unsuccessful in some way, rather than the reviews which shower a show with praise (because you are very unlikely to disagree with a good review… ‘But no, I thought my production was shit’).
The ADC theatre – home of all drama
The reviewer is supposed to be looking at the show objectively, something that someone involved in the show is surely unable to do. I’m not denying that fact that it is possible to ‘review the reviewer’ and respond to particularly pieces of criticism; perhaps a small explanation pertaining to a particular artistic decision; the set design for example, or a particular character choice, if the response is structured and composed in the right way.
What I don’t like, and what I think is completely inappropriate, is when the comments become personal. When people in the comment section start personally attacking the reviewer; questioning their ‘training’, their general knowledge of the theatre, and even resorting to outright rudeness and pretty bold, and sometimes offensive, allegations.
YOU SUCK REVIEWER!
By all means call the reviewer out if the review is badly written; if the grammar is bad and the sentences don’t make sense; if opinions seem to have been plucked out of thin air and if it is entirely obvious that the reviewer didn’t actually attend the show. However I am tired of reading personal attacks of the reviewer themselves in the comment sections, rather than the work they have produced, especially when the people commenting are involved in the production themselves. It’s unprofessional, and it makes you look like a sour grape, and certainly won’t persuade me to see your show.
Feel free to comment.
The Tab Guide to reviewing the reviewer
Controversial comments are congenial, but Rosie Brown implores you to hold back on the bitching.
CAMBRIDGE
It’s no secret that us Cambridge folk enjoy a good debate, a controversial opinion, reacting to anything we disagree with and, as one Tab theatre editor said, ‘creating an inadvertent shitstorm’.
But where do we draw the line in the case of reviews, which unlike abstract or light-hearted articles about weed smokers, actually involve personally critiquing someone’s work, most likely even someone familiar or that we’re actually acquainted with?
I think there’s no question about whether or not the regular theatre-goer, or indeed the average Joe can go ahead and comment. Comments are great. Comments are good. Comment comment comment. They arouse debate, they stimulate alternate opinions, and they are sometimes genuinely useful.
Like the Tab comments section, but not as fun
The real debate lies in whether it is ‘right’ or ‘appropriate’ to respond to a review in the comment section, or anywhere really, if one is involved in the production in some way; whether that be as an actor, director, writer or production team member. I refer in particular to those reviews which are negative, or which single out a particular element of the show or an actor as being unsuccessful in some way, rather than the reviews which shower a show with praise (because you are very unlikely to disagree with a good review… ‘But no, I thought my production was shit’).
The ADC theatre – home of all drama
The reviewer is supposed to be looking at the show objectively, something that someone involved in the show is surely unable to do. I’m not denying that fact that it is possible to ‘review the reviewer’ and respond to particularly pieces of criticism; perhaps a small explanation pertaining to a particular artistic decision; the set design for example, or a particular character choice, if the response is structured and composed in the right way.
What I don’t like, and what I think is completely inappropriate, is when the comments become personal. When people in the comment section start personally attacking the reviewer; questioning their ‘training’, their general knowledge of the theatre, and even resorting to outright rudeness and pretty bold, and sometimes offensive, allegations.
YOU SUCK REVIEWER!
By all means call the reviewer out if the review is badly written; if the grammar is bad and the sentences don’t make sense; if opinions seem to have been plucked out of thin air and if it is entirely obvious that the reviewer didn’t actually attend the show. However I am tired of reading personal attacks of the reviewer themselves in the comment sections, rather than the work they have produced, especially when the people commenting are involved in the production themselves. It’s unprofessional, and it makes you look like a sour grape, and certainly won’t persuade me to see your show.
Feel free to comment.
CAMBRIDGE
‘Maybe try a different course’: Ranking Cambridge University lecturers’ brutal comments
CAMBRIDGE
No wonder Cambridge students always look stressed
Quiz: Find out where you’d sit in the Cambridge University college boat club eight
CAMBRIDGE
You go to Cambridge and don’t row? How else do you spend your free time?
Cambridge University college to install climbing wall inside 150 year old church tower
CAMBRIDGE
Pembroke has already converted the church on Trumpington Street into an auditorium
Cambridge University to ban use of the term ‘Oxbridge’ due to elitist connotations
CAMBRIDGE
Anyone caught using the word will be forced to undertake a mandatory ‘inclusivity training’
St John’s College Cambridge now has control over the SJV choir’s social media
CAMBRIDGE
The petition to save the mixed choir is supported by the former archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams
Cambridge University temporarily halts funding from fossil fuel companies
CAMBRIDGE
A report found that donations from oil and gas companies posed a ‘high reputational risk’ for the university
Eight cafés to try in Cambridge as a student before you graduate from university
CAMBRIDGE
Spoiler alert: Fitzbillies isn’t the only coffee shop in Cambridge
St John’s College Cambridge mixed choir is being disbanded
CAMBRIDGE
The decision means female sopranos will no longer be able to sing in any chapel services
Cambridge University colleges as songs with women’s names in the title
CAMBRIDGE
Get ready to update your playlist immediately x
Cambridge reading week – yay or nay?
CAMBRIDGE
All this reading isn’t for the weak
Cambridge men lose on penalties at the 150th anniversary of Varsity football
CAMBRIDGE
Cambridge was forced to substitute its goalkeeper following an injury on the third minute
THE RESULTS: Cambridge vs Oxford women’s football 2024
CAMBRIDGE
A short summary of the Varsity match for those of you who know nothing about football
Cambridge’s smallest pub has reopened after four years
CAMBRIDGE
Here’s everything you need to know about The Rad, a tiny pub on King Street
Review: Blackadder Goes Forth – Cambridge Does Comic Relief
CAMBRIDGE
A performance that did justice to the much-loved British comedy
Paint thrown over Cambridge University West site building in protest of its ties to Israel
CAMBRIDGE
Cambridge’s Laboratory for Scientific Computing has been under fire for its links to arms companies
A moral alignment ranking of Cambridge college rowing blade designs
CAMBRIDGE
Totally objective (based on free speed and vibez)
A definitive ranking of Cambridge stash from ugly to just about wearable
CAMBRIDGE
It’s me and my puffer against the world
THE REVEAL: Cambridge’s Top 10 BNOCs 2024
CAMBRIDGE
Never have I ever kissed a BNOC…
Review: Emma
CAMBRIDGE
An Austenite’s dream! (and Jane’s own nightmare)
Who are the candidates running for election at the Cambridge Union?
CAMBRIDGE
Voting opens Thursday 7th March after the weekly debate
Everything Jack O’Connell has been up to since breaking all our hearts as Cook in Skins
UK
He’s now starring in the new Amy Winehouse biopic Back To Black
From absolute legends to losers, the definitive ranking of Coachella’s biggest headliners
UK
There’s been the best of shows, there’s been the worst of shows
Baby Reindeer’s confusing and symbolic ending explained: What happens to Donny and Martha?
UK
My head is spinning
Tori has finally spilled what her friendship status is now with the other MAFS Australia girls
UK
‘What those girls did to me was not friendship’
All of Taylor Swift’s sly digs at ex Joe Alwyn in new album The Tortured Poets Department
UK
No one is safe!
Madeleine complains that her MAFS Australia edit made her look like a ‘batsh*t crazy b*tch’
UK
The psychic medium said that producers ‘pushed on a relationship topic that she didn’t want to go into’
MAFS Australia bride says groom broke up with her ‘out of the blue’ and won’t reply to her
UK
‘He won’t reply to me. He hasn’t replied’
A body language expert says Jack and Tori are lying about having sex on MAFS Australia
UK
‘Do I think they had proper sex? No’
Everything Eden and Jayden have been up to since their messy run on MAFS Australia
UK
Apparently they broke up FOUR TIMES after filming finished
This is why everyone thinks Taylor Swift’s song thanK you aIMee is about Kim Kardashian
UK
The title literally spells out KIM!!
All the savage Matty Healy lyrics Taylor Swift sings on The Tortured Poets Department
UK
‘They shake their heads and say God help her when I tell them he’s my man’
Richard Gadd speaks about how similar Baby Reindeer’s Martha actually is to his real stalker
UK
She did actually send him over 41,071 emails and leave 350 hours of voicemails
Student at £43,000 a year private school ‘smashed the skulls’ of two students with hammer
UK
The 17-year-old also tried to kill a teacher in ‘horrific attack’
After a tumultous MAFS Australia 2024 homestay, are Lucinda and Timothy still together?
UK
Rooting for them ngl
What have Timothy and Lucinda been up to since their MAFS Australia 2024 homestay fight?
UK
They’re still besties!
Here’s where to watch Richard Gadd next if you’re obsessed with Netflix’s Baby Reindeer
UK
He’s in a police show with Stephen Graham!
Digs at Davide to Lorraine Kelly drama: What Ekin-Su has been up to since Celeb Big Brother
UK
She’s been in the headlines a lot lately
Inside Nava Mau’s vibey life when she’s not playing the best character in Baby Reindeer
UK
Fully obsessed with her
After their tense homestay, are Jack and Tori still together after MAFS Australia 2024?
UK
I need answers immediately
Yikes! A snippet of Taylor Swift’s new album has allegedly leaked and people are SLATING it
UK
‘We declared Charlie Puth should be a bigger artist’ is an actual lyric
Inside the life of Walton Goggins, the Fallout ghoul everyone is weirdly crushing on
UK
Yes, it’s possible to thirst after a man who looks like a carved pumpkin