Three legends are already ‘lined up’ for the next Love Island All Stars and this could save the show

It may only seem as though Love Island 2026 just wrapped up, and that’s because it did. But already we’re thinking to the next series of Love Island All Stars, as it’s been reported that three legendary Islanders are eyeing up a return.

All Stars has been around for three series now, so you might think that we’re running out of Islanders to have maximum impact, but I mean it when I say, Love Island producers have plenty more up their sleeves. 

Here’s who has already been rumoured for the next series of All Stars, that will kick off in the New Year.

Jack Fowler

via ITV

Guys, I don’t think I’d actually know what to do if Jack Fowler went back on Love Island. But apparently, this is looking very much likely. It’s been reported that producers have seen how much we’ve begged to have him back, and have been in contact. 

According to The Sun, he’s now “considering” his invite back to the villa. A source added: “For the first time this year it wasn’t a flat no from Jack’s side. Of course he might end up turning it down but there’s a glimmer of hope, at least.”

Matilda Draper

via ITV

Most Read

Celebrities are calling out Ariana Grande’s team for ‘absolutely appalling’ petal music video

The internet never forgets: The biggest male celeb nude leaks ever, and how they responded

Love Island’s over, so here’s every 2026 couple’s relationship status and who’s already split

2024 icon Matilda is apparently top of producers’ list, after things failed with Sean after the villa, and she recently broke up with her TOWIE boyfriend. She spoke on a podcast about being approached for All Stars last year, but she had a boyfriend. She said she had the “best time” on the show, and admitted on some days she thinks “oh get me back in there [the villa]”. 

A source told The Sun: “Matilda loved her time on Love Island in 2024 and was up for All Stars when they approached for the 2025 series. But then she got with Roman in late 2024 so she just thought there was no point.

“Of course they sadly split in March 2026, but the timings mean Matilda is in a good spot to sign up for All Stars ‘27. It’s very, very early days for All Stars and the cast won’t be anywhere near confirmed until December, if not January, but Matilda will likely be in the mix as she was a popular Islander with audience and cast alike.”

Billy Brown 

via ITV

After first appearing in the 2022 series, it’s now been claimed that Billy Brown has been “lined up” for his return. He has been rumoured for All Stars a couple of times now, but it would seem it’s not worked out, and bosses are keen to make it work this time around. Earlier this year, he was even flown out to the 2026 holding villa. 

A source told The Sun: “He’s really keen to be a big streamer and being on TV every night will only help that. He was lined up for series three but never made it out of holding – now he’s back in contact with ITV for series four.”

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.