Who’s the daddy? These three men face daunting reality they might now have a baby with Bonnie Blue

I never thought I’d see the day, but she’s given birth. Yep, Bonnie Blue has had a baby and now everyone has been left with the same question: Who’s the daddy?

And while it may seem potentially 1,057 men fit the frame, or 400-or-so if the baby was conceived at her “breeding mission” stunt, only three men have spoken out to say they believe they could be the father of the child. One even said Bonnie Blue had told him there’s a “high chance” he could be the dad. 

So, how do they really feel about it all? Here’s what they’ve said.

Potential baby daddy number one: Jak White

Bonnie and Jak

20-year-old Jak White is a well known OnlyFans creator. He attended the “breeding mission” event, and told The Tab afterwards that he was worried Bonnie was then carrying his baby. He called the day “crazy” and said while he had a great time, potentially becoming a father afterwards “wasn’t on my bingo card”.

He said he only had three minutes with her, and now has the reality he might have a lifetime of fatherhood ahead of him. When asked if he was worried about if he could be the father, Jak said: “Well yeah. It wasn’t on my bingo card for 2026. You don’t expect that to happen. I thought everything was planned and whatnot, but yeah it could happen right? And it did happen.”

Potential baby daddy number two: Owain Laing

Owain and Bonnie

Most Read

The Lion King composer ordered to pay comedian after $27m lawsuit over podcast joke backfires

He’s not in Death of the Pastor’s Wife, so where is Mica Miller’s first husband Jeremy Deas now?

Ralph Fiennes isn’t returning as Voldemort in Harry Potter, but here’s what he actually said

Owain Laing attended Bonnie’s most controversial stunt to date, when she turned her baby shower into an x-rated day of various different *activities*. He was seemingly there because he’d been at events before, and might now be the father of the baby. 

“I could be the dad. If it comes out with a little beard and a mullet, then it’s definitely mine,” Owain joked in a chat with The Tab. Over on Instagram, Owain shared a picture of him posing with Bonnie, when she was pregnant. “Unexpected plot twist,” was his caption. 

He should probably be worried, as he has a girlfriend. “Enjoying a trip in Rome knowing I have to tell her I could be Bonnie Blue’s baby daddy,” he said, in a video showing himself and his girlfriend out for dinner. “I need help lads,” the caption added.

But maybe it won’t be too much of a shock. After the event, Owain told The Tab: “I’ve got a Mrs and she was happy and knows Bonnie as she was there for the Bali shoot and they got along with each other.” Erm, ok?

Potential baby daddy number three: Tommy Lee

Bonnie with Tommy

Tommy Lee, a creator who’s worked with Bonnie and Lily Phillips, also spoke to The Tab about being at the baby shower, and admitted he is worried the baby is his. Tommy explained Bonnie told him “there’s a high chance that you’re the dad” so he felt he “had to be there” for the baby shower.

“I don’t think anything really sinks in until proven. But it’s still a big worry in the back of your mind, thinking about what do you do if it is,” he told US Weekly. “It’s not that I haven’t thought about it, I think about it, but you just don’t know what can you say? I don’t think there’s anything you can do. That’s it, really.” Someone sounds nervous!

For more like this, like The Tab on Facebook. Featured image via Instagram.