People have decoded the real reason Casey was so messy in voting game and it’s not a good look

Casey O’Gorman is once again embroiled in Love Island All Stars drama, this time after some messy voting that saw viewers dub him “jealous” of the other villa couples.

This is officially Casey’s THIRD time in the Love Island villa after failing to secure a long-lasting relationship in both his first stint in 2023 and his All Stars season one appearance. It’s getting a little tired, and even his bestie Tom Clare thinks so.

During Monday night’s episode, the Islanders gathered together for a messy game of voting on subjects such as most likely to cheat, most boring couple, and the person in the villa for clout. Casey argued that Ekin-Su and Curtis were most likely to cheat and Grace and Luca were the most boring.

While the moment could have just been Casey expertly stirring the pot, some people on Twitter have another theory.

Casey is ‘jealous’ of the other Love Island couples

During the game last night, after he voted for Ekin-Su and Curtis as the couple most likely to experience cheating, Casey explained: “They’ve been the only couple in here to close things off, and then gone back on their word.”

Curtis and Ekin-Su obviously didn’t take kindly to the comment, with the former replying: “It’s still early days and I owned up to making a mistake and everything, and that isn’t showing anything to do with cheating on the outside.”

casey thinking he gagged harriett by saying she was on love island 6 months ago as if he hasn’t been on this show for 3 consecutive januarys in a row😭😭😭😭big fat loser #LoveIslandAllStars pic.twitter.com/uzh9op8pC6

— mi♡01:27 AM☀️ (@r4indr0ps__) February 9, 2025

Though you could argue that Casey was merely playing the game, some have suggested that he’s trying to take down the more secure couples out of jealousy. Considering this is his third attempt at finding love in the villa, and the fact he admitted to being jealous of his mates’ relationships, this theory has got some legs.

Most Read

Guys! A FOURTH Islander has quit Love Island All Stars and this is so messy

Retiring, religion and legal troubles: The Buffy cast members we probably won’t see back

Doctor breaks down what is going on with Grace’s hair extensions on Love Island All Stars

One person wrote on Twitter: “Casey getting upset because he knows at least the other couples like each other and he had no other option but to stay with Gabby.”

“I think the other couples were threatened by Ekin and Curtis. This is a tactic. Eliminate the strongest couple,” another said.

A third person wrote: “I really want Ekin and Curtis to win now. Feel like the other couples are threatened by them and ganging up on.”

Yes, Casey is currently in a relationship with Gabby and technically has nothing to be jealous about, but people aren’t even certain they’re going to last on the outside, hence why Casey would be jealous of the more secure relationships.

Gabby piping up like Casey isn’t going to dump her in 3-5 business days #LoveIslandAllStars pic.twitter.com/EV48pyogJm

— LJ 🇯🇲 (@lajoyaxo) February 10, 2025

One person wrote: “Gabby piping up like Casey isn’t going to dump her in 3-5 business days.”

“Gabby is running her mouth a little too much for my liking, you’re coupled up with Casey focus on your imminent heartbreak love #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars,” another said.

Personally, I’m hoping Casey and Gabby are end game so we don’t have to see them on our TV screens again.

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.  

Credit: ITV