Casey isn’t the only person in the All Stars villa who has been on Love Island THREE times

Casey was the latest Islander to walk into the All Stars villa as a bombshell and it was the last thing anyone expected.

He was on the show last year alongside Tom, Molly and Callum, and people are ripping into him for going on Love Island for the third time.

“Producers are actually SO DESPERATE to be bringing back Casey, he’s literally been on Love Island 3 times like this is insane,” one wrote on X.

Another said: “Going on Love Island twice is embarrassing enough, but three times !! three years in a row !!! Someone needs to find Casey a job.”

However, he’s not actually the only one there who has been in the villa three times… Curtis has too!

going on love island twice is embarrassing enough, but three times !! three years in a row !!! someone needs to find casey a job #LoveIslandAllStars

— CERYS (@cerysl1ly) January 14, 2025

sorry Casey is sooo funny, how can you go on the same show 3 times

— tia rae (@TiaToldYouSo) January 14, 2025

People are totally forgetting that Curtis went on Love Island Games, so he’s actually been in the villa the same number of times as Casey.

He was on series five in 2019, then did the Love Island Games in 2023 and now he’s back for one more go in 2025.

Casey first appeared on Love Island in 2023, went into All Stars in 2024 and is back in 2025, so he’s gone into the villa every year.

Love Island Games saw contestants from across the world return for a second chance at finding love and the potential to win a $100,000 prize.

Favourites from the UK, US and Australia all competed in various challenges and Curtis was dumped on day six out of 17.

The show was filmed in a villa in Fiji, where they all lived and coupled up just like in the normal show, it was just a bit shorter.

Most Read

Hang on, how close are the Kardashians’ and Jenners’ houses to the Los Angeles fires?

Five Guys worker responds after Bonnie Blue ‘harassed’ him to sleep with her at work

The twisted meaning of Squid Game’s Mingle song where ‘Round and Round’ lyrics are super ironic

Georgia Steele, Liberty Poole and Toby Aromolaran all went on Love Island Games too, then were on the first season of All Stars.

Technically, that means there are five people who have been on Love Island three times. Surely they won’t go for a fourth?!

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.

Featured image by: ITV