Who was the villain of All Stars? This scientific ranking proves one Islander was the most evil

Love Island All Stars season two is now officially over so there has never been a better time to rank this year’s crop by how much they were the villain.

Villains are a staple of every Love Island season. Over the years we’ve seen some truly diabolical Islanders, from slimy lads such as Jonny Mitchell to Paige Thorne’s mean-girl behaviour. The show wouldn’t be the same without them and we simply love to hate.

Look, I have omitted some of the All Stars Islanders from this list because of the simple fact they aren’t controversial or have been too boring to stir the pot. This is a ranking of messy kings and queens only, with the person in the number one spot undoubtedly flexing Disney villain-level evil.

13. Curtis Pritchard

Curtis Pritchard’s only crime is being cringy as hell, but that doesn’t necessarily mean he’s villainous. In fact, I don’t think Curtis has got a malicious bone in his body.

12. Grace Jackson

Grace Jackson might look like the popular girl in school, but besides a few rude comments to Luca that people called out on Reddit, she lacks the depth for true villainy.

11. Casey O’Gorman

I flip-flop between liking Casey and utterly loathing him. Nonetheless, his argumentative nature earned him a spot on this list.

10. Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu

Ekin-Su has got all the goods of a villain. She can turn the waterworks on when it suits her, her shade is comparable to Maura Higgins’, and I’m pretty certain that every move she makes is calculated. However, she simply wasn’t as evil as her first Love Island gig in 2022.

9. Scott Thomas

Most Read

Revealed: The apparent texts Grace was sending around before Love Island All Stars

Right, what did Grace *actually* say in those Love Island screenshots and are they real?

Tasha finally breaks her silence on Andrew split and hints this is the really sad reason

Scott Thomas left the competition early after failing to find a match, but before he jumped on a plane back to the UK he was involved in a fight with Luca. People still can’t agree whose fault it was, but it takes two to tango and Scott is approaching 40 – grow up.

8. Luca Bish

Luca Bish attempted to revive his reputation after being branded toxic during his first stint. Did he succeed? No idea, but there is no denying that he still dipped his toe in controversial waters during All Stars. He had that fight with Scott, broke “bro-code” when sharing the Tina Stinnes truth bomb, and his apathetic personality had me questioning why he was even there.

Not evil per se, but definitely controversial.

7. Sammy Root

Sammy Root doesn’t have the main character energy of a villain, but you know what they say, keeping quiet is just as bad as the act itself. Sammy did essentially nothing to curb the rampage of his girlfriend Elma, in fact, he even threw in a few pointed jabs of his own from behind her shadow.

6. Harriett Blackmore

Harriett Blackmore didn’t have a particularly villainous arc, but one tense moment saw her forget she told Casey to “shut your f*****g mouth.” Did she black out in a fit of rage? Or does she genuinely not realise how her words affect people? Either way, it’s villainous to a tea.

5. Samie Elishi

I quite liked Samie during her initial Love Island run, but during season two of All Stars she seemed to be in the villa for one reason: Steal Luca away from Grace. Everything she did revolved around this, and even after being dumped, she was still adding fuel to the fire.

4. Kaz Crossley

These next three people became the Regina George, Gretchen Wieners, and Karen Smith of the Love Island universe. Kaz was seemingly the brains of the operation, using her TikTok to drop truth bomb after truth bomb, and I ate it all up and wanted seconds. Iconic, but very very messy.

2. Elma Pazar

Elmo Pazar, as Scott Scott van-der-Sluis called her, was completely forgettable during her first Love Island stay. She went the complete opposite direction this time around and her voice became quite grating by the end of the show.

Elma was rude, quick-tempered, and argumentative, and seemed to single out Ekin-Su despite literally basing her hair cut on hers.

1. Olivia Hawkins

She was the villain of her season and the villain of All Stars Two so Olivia Hawkins might just be a villain full stop. Of course, the pinnacle of her villainous reign – her needle and spinning wheel you could say – was the texting drama involving Grace. It just wasn’t needed.

For all the latest Love Island news, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.

Featured image credit: ITV