Chasing him to a five-minute hangout: All of the ‘Peter Pan girl’s’ videos in one place

The ‘Peter Pan girl’, Toni Kulusich, has finally spoken out after people dug through hundreds of her videos to pick apart her interactions with the iconic character. 

Toni went viral earlier this month when people accused her of pestering the famous Lost Boy. She’d been visiting the park once a week for around 10 years, and though her TikTok content is generally Disney-themed, she has a particular fascination for Peter after a “magical” experience in her youth. Despite being “proud” of being a Disney adult, she said it was a “pretty tough” week amidst being dragged on the internet. 

Responding to the backlash, she said in a recent interview: “People can take something really small and turn it into something big without even knowing what it’s truly about. I’ve never expected to, like, blow up this much – of like, the entire internet to know I exist.”

She’s going to continue her love for Peter Pan, so here are the videos so far. 

She gave Peter Pan a doll of himself 

@babytoni99

In honor of the last day 💚✨ #peterpan #disneyland

♬ original sound – Toni

In this video, Toni was watching the Celebrate Happy Cavalcade parade, which was for Disneyland’s 70th anniversary. Peter Pan ran over to her as she shook a doll of his likeness in his direction. He picked it up, went for a fly with it, and then returned it to Toni. 

10 years of Peter Pan 

@babytoni99

2016—> 2026 #peterpan

♬ původní zvuk – tylacekdacice

This video has since been viewed 13.1 million times, and it showed Toni through the years as she visited various Peter Pans at the park. You quite literally see her grow up, and though her hairstyle has changed, her love for the Lost Boy is timeless. 

We all have that one thing, and hers is Peter Pan. 

This subtle brag was the first time she addressed the drama 

@babytoni99

Just saying; if he didn’t wanna be around me he would literally run away🏃💨

♬ original sound – grace

In August, Toni bragged about how she managed to get a five-minute video with Peter Pan – more on that later. 

She somewhat addressed the conversation at the time, writing in the caption: “Just saying; if he didn’t wanna be around me he would literally run away.”

This interaction went viral 

@babytoni99

I think he ended up liking the idea #peterpan

♬ original sound – Toni

This video, which showed her giving Peter Pan a handmade crochet toy, went particularly viral on Twitter. Though the interaction seemed positive enough, with the two exchanging jokes, people claimed that he was uncomfortable. 

This is the five-minute vlog 

Most Read

The male reality TV stars whose nudes were leaked, and the Love Islander who now does gay p*rn

‘I lost half of my soul’: Hayden Panettiere shared heartbreak after brother died in 2023 aged 28

I was Peter Pan at Disney World, and my stalker’s ‘disturbing’ questions were only half of it

@babytoni99

Another adventure with the green bean💚🫶🏻✨ #peterpan #disneyland

♬ original sound – Toni

The video before was only a small portion of a much longer video, and in the five-minute vlog, Toni and Peter walked around the park as they chatted. They ran into Alice and the Mad Hatter before Peter attempted to return Toni’s kindness with a gift of his own. He randomly settled on a wood chip and some sticks. 

There’s another nostalgic montage 

@babytoni99

Forever a lost girl💚✨ #peterpan #disneyland

♬ suono originale – concertsv

Set to Billy Joel’s Piano Man, this video again showed Toni and Peter over the years. Though the actor changed, her love for him remained the same. 

Points for consistency!

There are a few relationship-type videos 

@babytoni99

The things I would do to go back to 2017 #peterpan

♬ សំឡេងដើម – myung’s . – myung’s .

One of the biggest arguments against Toni has been the parasocial aspect of their relationship; He’s literally a paid actor whose job is to interact with the public. The criticism was specifically targeted at the videos where Toni makes it seem like their relationship is something more than it is. 

In this one, set to The One That Got Away by Katy Perry, Toni was much younger as she interacted with the character. 

She carried around a dinosaur for nine weeks 

@babytoni99

Mission give Peter pan a green Dino complete!✅🦖✨ #peterpan #disneyland #disneyparks #peterpandisneyland #magicalmoments

♬ original sound – Toni

Peter Pan and Toni agreed that she’d make him a dinosaur out of yarn, and though she said she would return with it in a week, she was ultimately left carrying it around the park for nine weeks before giving it to him. 

He seemed generally thrilled when she gave it to him, and they named it Petersaurus Rex. 

“Oh, he has a hat just like mine,” Peter replied. 

There are obviously many (many) more videos than this, some dating back to as early as 2015, but this selection is what people are really talking about. 

And there will be more in the future. Though the internet can be cruel, Toni is maintaining her love for Peter Pan, and we love that for her. 

For more like this, like The Tab on Facebook.

Featured image credit: TikTok