Why HBO is remaking Harry Potter as a TV show, with the exact same story all over again

They should’ve done a spin-off

Everyone’s slating the upcoming HBO Harry Potter series once again after the first clip was released this week, and the same question always rolls around: Why are they remaking the exact same story? Money, obviously. But here’s everything the directors have said about why they’ve chosen to recreate the same story, rather than make a spin-off, as many think they should have. 

Coming to HBO Max on Christmas Day, the series is an exact remake of the Harry Potter books by JK Rowling, which means it’s also a direct recreation of the films. The first series is Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, and it’s already been renewed for a second series, which will be Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.

It’s been controversial ever since it was announced. JK Rowling getting even richer after her horrific transphobic views is part of the problem, and the main thing people just can’t get on board with is that the HBO series is going to be the same story we all know and love, but with new actors. It’s just strange, considering it hasn’t even been that long since the movies. We don’t need a remake. 

Except, the creators think we do. Their main reasoning for recreating Harry Potter is to add more details from the books that simply couldn’t fit into a two-hour film. According to them, having a whole series that covers each book allows them to explore parts of the story we haven’t seen before, and develop each character’s lore.

Speaking at an HBO Max showcase in December 2024, the showrunner and lead writer, Francesca Gardiner, said: “We’re both massively fond of the movies, they’re amazing, what an amazing feat of creative pursuits. It’s a hard act to follow no doubt; it’s something to take those books – so rich – and to pack them into two hours is extraordinary, but we get a bigger sandpit to play in and that really excites me.”

She continued: “We get to explore Hogwarts, we will see things we haven’t seen, we’ll get to have some fun with Peeves in the corridors.”

The director and executive producer, Mark Mylod, similarly said at a presentation: “We have eight hours to tell this first book so we can dig into depths and real crevices of Hogwarts and the similarities between the Muggle and Magic world, to dig into that with a beautiful attention to detail. It really is an evolution, our approach is not to undermine what was done previously. We simply want to evolve.

Credit: HBO

He added: “There are elements we don’t want to mess with such as the Great Hall, but other elements of Hogwarts we will expand on them.”

HBO’s Chairman Casey Bloys also told Variety that the series is all about “spending more time with characters and story” and having “the freedom to let it breathe a little bit more and explore the world a bit more”. 

But the question remains: Do we really need to expand the story on screen? Everyone’s happy with the way the story was told in the films. If people want more lore, they can read the books. A spin-off that explores other parts of the franchise would have made so much more sense. 

For more like this, like The Tab on Facebook. Featured image credit: HBO

More on: Harry Potter TV