HBO released the first Harry Potter clip and people are fuming over ‘cringy’ book change

It takes away all the magic

HBO has released the first-ever clip from the upcoming Harry Potter series, and people are fuming because the Hogwarts students are all chanting “Dumbledore” when that doesn’t ever happen in the books – and it’s so cringy. 

The series is releasing on HBO Max on Christmas Day, and it’s pretty controversial because it’s literally a direct remake of the Harry Potter books… the story we already know and love. HBO promised that the series will be a “very faithful” adaptation of JK Rowling’s original novels, yet they’re adding loads of things that were never mentioned in the books. 

The first 90-second clip dropped on Sunday, and it’s the scene where the students are all having their start-of-term banquet in the Great Hall after arriving at Hogwarts. 

Credit: HBO

It begins with the students all banging their hands on the tables in unison as they chant “Dumbledore!” over and over again like they’re at a football game. When he arrives in the Great Hall, they all cheer. Harry then turns to Ron and says, “Is Dumbledore a bit mad?” to which Ron replies, “Yep, totally off his rocker.”

After that, Dumbledore clicks his fingers, and all the food appears on the tables. We then see a conversation between Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall as they talk about Harry arriving at Hogwarts and being put in Gryffindor. 

However, in the books and the original films, the students never chant Dumbledore’s name. People think the whole thing just feels cringy and takes away from the headmaster’s mythical, wise aura. It turns him into some sort of celebrity rather than the powerful, enchanting wizard he is. 

In the novels, Dumbledore is met with awe as he says, “Before we begin our banquet, I would like to say a few words. And here they are: Nitwit! Blubber! Oddment! Tweak! Thank you.” Harry Potter then turns to Percy Weasley and asks, “Is he — a bit mad?” before Percy replies: “Mad? He’s a genius! Best wizard in the world! But he is a bit mad, yes. Potatoes, Harry?” 

One person wrote on Twitter: “Why the bloody hell are they chanting ‘Dumbledore!’, cringe fest.” Someone else agreed: “Why the heck are they chanting Dumbledore???? He’s literally basically the principal of the school. It’s just weird and takes away from his mythical, mysterious and powerful vibe.”

A third person added: “Soo… I wasn’t the only one turned off by that scene. It didn’t feel right – them chanting in their first year took away Dumbledore’s majestic aura. I don’t know… and his iron-curled beard… the school food trays… all meeehh.. no warm vibes… no cosy feelings… no magic.”

“Leaving aside the politics of this, I thought the ENTIRE POINT of this Harry Potter remake was to have it be as faithful to the books as possible, and yet here we have the kids chanting Dumbledore’s name (never happens in the book) in a scene that could be mistaken for AI slop?” someone else said. 

Well, that was a bad start. 

For more like this, like The Tab on Facebook. Featured image credit: HBO

More on: Harry Potter TV