Every single reason the upcoming HBO Harry Potter series just feels weird and off
There are so many things wrong with it
This week, a tweet went viral saying the reason the HBO Harry Potter series feels off is that the actors look like they know they’re in a Harry Potter movie. Once you see it, you can’t unsee it, but that’s not the only reason it feels strange. From the colour grading to the lack of magic, here are all the reasons people just can’t get on board with it.
The colour grading is so bad
Ever since the first trailer was released, people have been slating the colour grading. And it really is that bad. The colours are so dull and lifeless. Everything just looks grey, and it really takes away the magic.
Another example of changing the color grading in the New Harry Potter series to make it look more warm like the OG. You still have time HBO pic.twitter.com/tR0AsLrjse
— Akío Aslan🧑🏼🎨 (@akioaslan) November 16, 2026
There are brand new scenes and lines
HBO promised that the remake would be “faithful” to the original books. But then they’re adding weird new lines like the students chanting “Dumbledore” that were never in the novels.
There’s an uncanny familiarity
Any reboot of a huge franchise is always going to have this issue, but there’s a weird familiarity that just feels off. We already know the story and the characters, and some of the sets are the same, but the cast and lots of other details are completely different. It’s unsettling.
The actors are too perfect
Something that made the Harry Potter films so special is that they were all just normal kids who were relatable. In the remake, the actors look so perfect. Like, Dominic McLaughlin has such flawless teeth when he’s meant to be playing an 11-year-old who’s had a deprived and neglected childhood. This is no shade to the actor – he’s great. And he has great teeth. It’s all on HBO’s casting.
It’s the teeth, man.
An 11-year-old should have an 11-year-old’s smile. But let me be clear… I do NOT condone bullying this kid! I’m critiquing the producers, not him. They’re the ones who cast a kid with veneer-like teeth.
Further proof they don’t know what they’re doing. pic.twitter.com/TGYm3DHBXT
— Tyler Dean McDowell (@_TylerDean) November 16, 2026
JK Rowling… enough said
The whole series has a negative undertone thanks to JK Rowling profiting off it after making some horrifying public comments about gender identity and transgender rights, like arguing that trans women shouldn’t have access to single-sex spaces.
They look like they know they’re in a Harry Potter movie
As someone on Twitter put it this week: “The best way to describe the new Harry Potter series is that they all look like they’re fully aware that they’re in a Harry Potter series.” It almost looks like a skit.
It’s just not capturing the magic in the same way
And for all of these reasons, the series just isn’t capturing the magic as it should. Okay, we’ve only seen tiny snippets so far, and the full series could be different, but I’m not getting that warm, cosy feeling that the original films give.
For more like this, like The Tab on Facebook. Featured image credit: HBO






