The 17 Islanders Toni didn’t bother to follow on Instagram after she won Love Island

Toni Laites won Love Island 2025, making absolute history as the first American to ever take the title. And honestly, did anyone deserve it more? Not only was she the absolute icon of the series – always standing on business, always centre of attention when she didn’t even try to be – but she fell for Cach. Cach of course being the nicest lad to literally ever live. Instant national treasure. Now the glory of the win settles and she got her phone back, it’s interesting to have a look at who Toni followed on Instagram after Love Island – because not everyone got a follow. She had many feuds in that villa, but even some of her enemies got a follow.

Here’s a rundown of everyone who Toni didn’t give a follow to after she got her phone back and won Love Island 2025.

The expected… 

Let’s not beat around the bush – Toni had her fair share of drama in the villa and there are certain people who I didn’t think she’d follow. Some of these, like Meg, Dejon, Helena, Emily all actually DID get followed.

But the ones that didn’t were of course Harrison and Lauren – which makes so much sense. Why would she want to see what they get up to? I don’t and I wasn’t even involved! Blu also didn’t get a follow, which makes sense because he spent his entire villa return trying to have a fight with her. She also didn’t follow Ben, and makes sense because they never really saw eye to eye.

That’s four so far.

The big names she spent a considerable amount of time with who didn’t get a follow

Most Read

Guys, after six months you can finally see footage from Bonnie Blue’s 1000 guys in 12 hours

18-year-old lad from Bonnie Blue’s classroom scene reveals what the experience was really like

The wages the Love Island 2025 cast earned in jobs before the show prove who needs the £50k

Some Islanders we never saw her have major drama with but who were big characters in the villa also didn’t get a follow. These include Emma – Harry’s ex. She also never followed Boris, or Giorgio, or Shea. She also never followed Remell – very real for that. Two OG Islanders she snubbed were Tommy (even though Lucy got a follow) and Sophie – although she barely spent any time with Sophie to be fair. But considering she’s followed some Casa girls she literally never met, it’s interesting!

That takes us to 11!

Six more irrelevant dregs

These last few make a lot of sense why they didn’t get a follow because she either never met them or they were in the villa for, like, a day. Poppy, Caprice and Will snubbed – sleepover Islanders she never met. But she also never met Casa Amor girls like Yaz (of X factor fame) but Yaz got a follow.

That just leaves three lads she met but didn’t follow – Ryan who was there VERY briefly, and Chris the Casa Amor ghost. Oh, and poor Martin who is best known for a bad kiss.

That’s the grand total of 17 Love Island cast members that Toni never bothered to follow on Instagram (at the time of publication).

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.