Chris Watts’ ‘wife’ speaks out after he calls off jail wedding and starts relationships with male inmates

‘There is so much more to it’

She was set to become the wife of convicted killer Chris Watts, but now Lizzie Henderson is speaking out after her wedding was called off. 

Watts is currently serving a life sentence with no chance of parole for the 2018 murders of his pregnant wife Shanann Watts, and their two young daughters, four-year-old Bella and three-year-old Celeste. He is jailed at a maximum-security prison in Wisconsin.

Last week, it was reported that Chris Watts has had a string of romantic relationships in jail, including sexual relations with other male inmates. This was after ending things with a woman he had vowed to marry behind bars. 

Just one month ago, it was reported Watts had broken things off with Lizzie Henderson. He was reported to have struck up a relationship in prison with the real estate agent, and she relocated to Wisconsin, in order to be closer to him.

Lizzie Henderson was going to become the wife of Chris Watts

A photo of Lizzie from LinkedIn

Prior to the abrupt breakup, Lizzie had already started calling herself Lizzie Watts, and applied to marry Watts within the prison system. Photos showed her wearing a wedding ring, and prison records show she visited Watts 20 times in 2025, and also spent Christmas Day with him in 2024. The couple are said to have “got physical” in visits, with one witness describing a “steamy makeout session” one time Lizzie was at the jail. 

MailOnline has since tracked down Lizzie, and reported she has replaced her wedding band, having taken it off and instead getting a tattoo of a band on her finger. She told the reporter she was “doing good” but is said to have got less happy as their chat about Watts went on. 

“A lot of stuff happened after,” she told the publication, referring to the moment her engagement to Watts was revealed. “There is so much more to it.” She added: “I don’t want to talk about anything about that because that really put me in a really bad light.” 

However, she did share more. Her responses were described as “incoherent” as she spoke of “doing it for God… no matter who it is” when she was asked if she was still in contact with Watts. 

Chris Watts

via Netflix

Lizzie said the way she was treated after getting engaged to Watts was “a danger to me” and “would have scared the average person”. The publication said she hinted her engagement had caused rifts within her family. 

She went on to deny claims she had uprooted her life to move closer to Watts, and said: “I chose to work here, I did not come out here for Chris. I got a promotion to come out here.” Lizzie was also asked if her relationship with him had affected any relationships with people at the grocery store she also works at. “I am still cordial with everyone. It made me realise some things are not that important,” she said. 

Watts was reported to have dumped Lizzie, because “God told him to”. A family source confirmed Watts’ mother Cindy was particularly concerned about the marriage, too. Watts went on to tell Lizzie that he no longer had “peace” in their relationship, and he believed God was sending a sign they shouldn’t be together.

The chilling story of Watts’ crimes was told in American Murder: The Family Next Door, which first aired on Netflix in 2020.

American Murder: The Family Next Door is available on Netflix now. For all the latest Netflix news and drops, like The Holy Church of Netflix on Facebook. 

More on: Netflix News US