University of York abortion discussion sparks backlash after Pro-Life Society ratification
The York Union hosted a conversation on abortion in the UK
An open discussion on abortion between the Black Feminist Society and the newly ratified Pro-Life Society at the University of York has sparked backlash.
The discussion took place on Thursday 12th November, just 24 hours after the Pro-Life Society was officially ratified by the University of York Students’ Union.
The society’s ratification and the decision to host the conversation have since drawn criticism from several student societies, with some expressing concerns over the Students’ Union’s decision.
The conversation was organised around key points of discussion
The decision to discuss the issue of abortion in a conversation and not a debate was a deliberate choice of the SU, in order prevent from either side trying to win the conversation. Instead the framework of the evening sought provide both sides of a discussion with an equal opportunity to explain and defend their position.
Both sides discussed arguments on the following topics, from “what does UK law on abortion currently say” to “how does abortion work in practice in the UK to the criminality around abortion.”
The conversation was structured to allow each side a minute to pose their opinions and arguments, followed by a Q&A from the audience.
Before the conversation began, a representative from The York Union, speaking on behalf of the Student Union, explained that the university doesn’t support actions which exclude people. As such, they intended for the evening to be carried out with respect, fairness and compassion.
‘Abortion is a topic the most people will have an opinion on’
Before the conversation began, The York Tab spoke to the Black Feminist Society about the evening.
Speaking to their President and Secretary, they explained the importance of having this conversation: “Abortion is a topic the most people will have an opinion on and when lots of people have an opinion on one thing, a lot of those opinions will diverge.”
They went on to explain: “We think it is important to facilitate a space where everyone can say what they believe.”
When discussing the nature of the conversation taking place on a university campus, the President told The York Tab: “This is the last space before you leave a bubble. We want to, through our society, promote values in talking to people who don’t agree with you.”
Discussing the importance of the conversation, The York Pro-Life Society told The York Tab: “Many students will not have had an opportunity to hear a respectful and organised debate on abortion before.
“Particularly in times of extreme political polarisation, it is critical that people can see that those who disagree with them are people deserving of basic dignity and respect.”
When asked about the involvement of the SU in the conversation, the spokesperson shared: “It’s important that the SU facilitates conversations like these because universities are supposed to be places of intellectual rigour, where competing ideas are put head to head, so we can find a better solution for the society we live in.”
The event received backlash before it began
View this post on Instagram
Facilitated by The York Union, Thursday’s discussion received backlash before either party had even sat down to explain their side of the argument.
Taking to Instagram in the days leading up to the conversation, the President of the Black Feminist Society, Evelyn Sonar, sought to explain the society’s decision to partake in the debate.
She shared in a statement: “At the start of this academic year, the pro-life society asked us for a debate. My committee and I felt, and still feel, that ‘debate’, as it has come to be associated in the public square today, was and is an inappropriate mechanism for addressing a topic we see and understand as being settled: Access to safe abortion is a necessary freedom all women need to have to ensure the protection of their bodily autonomy and well-being.”
This was a statement that was supported by The York Union, who chaired and moderated the conversation.
When asked about backlash the conversation brought, York Pro-Life replied: “We don’t care. The Only think necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men and women to do nothing.”
The Pro-Life society was only ratified the day before
View this post on Instagram
The conversation which took place on the evening of Thursday 12th November was timely, as the Pro-Life Society was ratified just 24 hours prior, on Wednesday 11th November.
In a statement on its Instagram about the ratification, the Pro-Life Society shared: “We have finally been ratified with the University of York Student Union. Our victory today belongs to all the York alumni who sought to give a voice to the voiceless unborn.
“We will fight the societal conditions which stack the odd against young people facing pregnancy.”
It added in the same statement: “We are a secular society, open to all, ready to defend life according to the principles of all religions, and none.”
The society has held events since last semester, with talks consisting of a variety topics, including “Why Christians support abortion and abortion” and “Down Syndrome: Acceptable eugenics.”
‘We see this as yet another step that the SU has made in the wrong direction’
Since the SU decided to ratify the society, many societies have criticised it. Notably, the University of York’s Restore Britain Society took to Instagram to share a statement: “We would like to emphasise that we do not associate with the newly ratified Pro-Life Society, despite attempts to conflate us with them.”
Moreover, other societies, including the Black Feminist Society, The York Green Society, and the Diversity Politics Society, have all expressed their disagreement with the SU’s decision.
The UoY Green Party Society have shared in a statement posted on Instagram: “We are deeply disappointed to see that the ‘Pro-Life’ (Anti-Choice) Society has been ratified by the SU.
“We see this as yet another step that the SU has made in the wrong direction by allowing far-right groups that have the potential to actively cause harm on and off campus to be affiliated with it.”
‘We are very glad to finally be ratified’
The York Pro-Life Society spoke to The York Tab about the ratification. A spokesperson for the society shared: “We are very glad to finally be ratified. It’s taken a long time, with many hurdles, but we’re here.
“We’d already had tonnes of students expressing interest in joining, now we can finally offer them formal membership.”
If you or anyone you know has been affected by trauma, distress, or a shocking incident, please do not hesitate to reach out for support. You can contact organisations such as Samaritans or Mind for confidential help and advice.
You can contact Samaritans by calling 116 123. They are available 24/7 to provide emotional support to anyone in distress.
Mind offers advice and support for anyone struggling with mental health. You can contact them on 0300 123 3393 or visit their website for further information.
York Pro-Life Society, YUSU, and the University of York were contacted for comment.






