Inside Jimmy’s complex dating history after Love Is Blind, from moving on to reuniting with ex
He was in a relationship for almost a year
Jimmy had quite a tumultuous time on Love Is Blind, particularly because he ended up with Chelsea Blackwell, who told him she looks like Megan Fox. The thing is, he’s been pretty busy since the show, so we thought we’d look into Jimmy’s complex dating history.
Jimmy and Chelsea tried again after Love Is Blind
Jimmy and Chelsea didn’t completely end their relationship on Love Is Blind, even though they argued a lot. They actually gave things another go after filming wrapped, but decided they work better as friends, and that they’d support each other in new relationships.
He moved on with a woman called Farrah
View this post on Instagram
Jimmy was in a relationship with Farrah Colonna, who he started dating over a year ago. He was first pictured holding hands with her as the pair attended the Netflix Is A Joke festival. While she’s kept up photos with him on her Instagram, she unfollowed him months ago.
The last photo she shared of them together was in July 2025, while he has deleted any trace of her from his socials, and unfollowed her. They first went Instagram-official back in mid-2024, and on Farrah’s birthday, in February, he shared more photos of them together.
He wrote: “I’m so happy I get to celebrate with you today, and I feel incredibly lucky to be loved by you!!!” Since their split, Farrah has embraced her faith in God on socials, and wrote, “This past year has been so rewarding and also extremely challenging.”
Jimmy recently reunited with Chelsea
@jimmypresnell2 Our fav audio @Chelseablackwell 😭😭 #fyp #loveisblind #loveisblindseason6
Um, weirdly, Jimmy has just moved into the same apartment complex as Chelsea, but for now, are only saying they’re friends. Seems a bit fishy to me, especially because he said they’re “super close” in a recent video update on his temporary new address.
He said he’s planning a mini vacation to Miami and will be staying there for three months. And next thing you know, Jimmy and Chelsea are only in the same video together, smiling away and everyone’s begging them to give it another try.
They’ve been on dinner dates (or shall we call them friendship meet-ups) and gone for drinks, but he’s still been busy replying to flirty comments on his new selfies, so he’s either a huge flirt or they really are just friends. Still ship them though!
He’s been spotted with a Love Island USA star
View this post on Instagram
Jimmy looked pretty close with Love Island USA star Kassy on the red carpet. They both follow each other on Instagram, but she is rumoured to be taking part in Perfect Match very soon, with Weston Richey from Vanderpump Rules, so they’re likely just friends.
For all the latest reality TV cast member news, scandals, gossip and updates – like Reality Shrine on Facebook.