There's rumours Love Island USA's Nic has a girlfriend called Molly

Nic from Love Island USA may have left the show all loved-up with Olandria, but there’s now rumours going round that he has a secret girlfriend. Pictures of him kissing a mystery blonde lady called Molly are going round, and they’ve been spotted together a lot.

Photos show them both wearing the same T-shirts, as well as the mystery woman being on the same bus as him, and going to different locations. However, a guy called Jake has claimed under Nic’s live that Molly is his girlfriend, and Jake is one of Nic’s close friends.

Meet Nic's New Girlfriend
byu/yygghhhjhhhhhhhhj inLoveIslandUSA_

Looking at Jake’s Instagram though, he appears to just be friends with Molly. They refer to each other as “besties” on a recent yacht trip while it looks like Molly spends most of her time at her coffee shop, Wells Coffee, which Nic doesn’t even follow on Instagram.

People are convinced that Nic took Molly as plus one to Celsius, to the Diplo club, and are also claiming she was spotted with him strolling around at Philadelphia. There’s also rumours he took her with him to a yacht party and that he even stayed at her apartment.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Jake Buffaline (@jakebuffaline)

Photos of Nic and Molly were shared at a Diplo concert, but Jake was actually there dancing with her, and was cropped out. Some people are now convinced that Jake is covering up his friend’s secret relationship as the speculation continues online.

Since Jake finally came out to confirm that Molly is his girlfriend, I hope y’all start leaving that man’s friends and every blonde girl around him alone.

Also, cropping Jake out of multiple shots including the Diplo’s concert and Celcius brand trip is weird af. Seek help! 🥴 https://t.co/WHIdws9Rbt pic.twitter.com/dkGMDw2o12

— Bambi (@BambiTMT) December 11, 2025