Predicting who will win The Celebrity Traitors, based on who’s best at their role

The Celebrity Traitors has taken the nation by storm. From Celia Imrie’s unforgettable fart to Alan Carr’s hilarious one-liners, this season has been full of moments we won’t forget. Unsurprisingly, the series has been a massive hit for the BBC, with over 11.7 million viewers tuning in for the first episode. As people have noticed, things aren’t exactly going according to plan for the faithful. After six episodes, they’ve lost 10 members and haven’t managed to uncover a single traitor, leaving questions about who will be the winner.

So far, Alan Carr, Cat Burns, and Jonathan Ross remain the traitors. With only six faithfuls and three episodes left, tensions are running high. Here’s our take on who’s most likely to win based on how well they’ve been playing their roles.

9. Celia Imrie, faithful

Credit: BBC

I love Celia, and I genuinely don’t think any of the traitors have the heart to murder her. She’s also stayed pretty much under the radar throughout the whole show. The only reason I’m putting her last is because I fully believe the theory that she’s got her own secret role.

8. Joe Marler, faithful

Credit: BBC

Joe is likeable and straightforward, but strategy hasn’t exactly been his strong suit. His physical presence makes him a target, and in a game that rewards cunning over strength, he seems unlikely to outwit the more devious contestants.

7. Kate Garraway, faithful

Credit: BBC

Most Read

A sad update on AJ Owens’ kids, two years after their mum was killed by Susan Lorincz

The wages the MAFS UK 2025 cast earned before the show prove who *really* needs fame

Ok, here’s exactly what MAFS’ Keye actually does for work after ‘six figure salary’ comments

Kate has brought energy and personality, but her unpredictable moves have made her an easy target. If I were in castle, I know I’d be voting for her as a traitor. She hasn’t shown the strategic awareness needed to survive the final rounds. Unless luck suddenly swings her way, she’s unlikely to win.

6. Jonathan Ross, traitor

Credit: BBC

Jonathan has played a smooth game so far. His confidence and charm make him dangerous, and he could potentially sneak to the end. That said, he’s drawn a lot of suspicion this week. It seems like everybody has mentioned his name, but they just won’t vote him out. Personally, I think enough will be enough and he’ll be the next to be banished.

5. Lucy Beaumont, faithful

Credit: BBC

Not to be rude, but I didn’t know who she was until Celebrity Traitors, which I think is playing to her advantage. While her general likeability could help her survive a few rounds, in a game built on secrecy and manipulation, I can’t help but feel she’s unlikely to come out on top.

4. David Olusoga, faithful

Credit: BBC

David has also kept relatively under the radar throughout the game, hidden by some of the other bigger names. He’s definitely rational, steady, and analytical, and is a good voice of reason amongst all the chaos. Personally, I think he can appear too logical — it’ll be easy for traitors to label him as cold or calculating.

3. Cat Burns, traitor

Credit: BBC

Cat has been quietly clever, blending in and staying under the radar. She’s smart, trusted, and in exactly the kind of position that can carry a Traitor far. However, with Alan still in play, she’s strong but not unbeatable — she could reach the end if she plays her cards perfectly.

2. Nick Mohammed, faithful

Credit: BBC

Nick has been quietly excelling as a faithful. Observant, clever, and underestimated, he’s in a strong position to survive to the very end. If the Traitors slip up, Nick could walk away with the prize, though he’ll need a bit of luck and perfect timing to beat the Traitors.

1. Alan Carr, traitor

Credit: BBC

Alan is the frontrunner and, in my opinion, the most likely winner. He’s very charming and adept at manipulating the game without drawing too much suspicion, meaning he’s consistently stayed ahead. Unless something completely unexpected happens, Alan is poised to take it all.

And of course, the big question remains: what happens if only Traitors are left by the end? If all Faithfuls are eliminated, the Traitors get all the money. If just one traitor remains, that individual walks away with the entire prize.

The final episode airs on Thursday 6th November at 9pm, and the Celebrity Traitors winner will be crowned.

For more like this, like The Tab on Facebook.

Featured image credit: BBC