Basic and boring to runway ready: A brutal ranking of the Love Island cast by fashion game

The Love Island All Stars cast might be in the South African villa to find the one, but with dozens of cameras pointing right at them there has never been a better time to flex their fashion sense.

Over the years we’ve had some true runaway queens on Love Island. Though Maura Higgins instantly jumps to mind, other fashionable Islanders might include Zara McDermott, Tasha Ghouri, Jordan Hames, Dami Hope, and Indiyah Polack.

The second season of All Stars is also bustling with fashion talent, and though some are clearly better than others, it’s worth mentioning that no one is completely lacking in style. As someone currently wearing shorts in January, I am obviously more than qualified to judge their looks – take a peek.

16. Marcel Somerville

Marcel is the t-shirt and jeans type through and through and there is nothing necessarily wrong with that.

15. Curtis Pritchard

My 2025 New Year’s resolution was to stop being mean about Curtis so I’m going to let this Dwayne The Rock Johnson cosplay speak for itself.

14. Ron Hall

Ron knows how to put together an outfit but Ferrari baseball caps are not the slam dunk he thinks they are.

13. Tina Stinnes

Tina’s fashion moments are largely swimwear, which makes sense given she has her own swimwear brand.

12. Gabby Allen

Being a personal trainer and dancer doesn’t exactly call for many high-fashion moments.

11. Nas Majeed

Nas is the best-dressed sports presenter out there, which is honestly not saying much.

10. Grace Jackson

Grace knows her angles, colours, and fabrics, and yet, I can’t help but feel that we’ve seen it 1,000 times.

9. Elma Pazar

Most Read

It’s finally here: Watch the full video of Bonnie Blue’s 1,000 guys in 12 hours challenge

The brutal reason Bonnie Blue’s 1,000 guys in 12 hours video has been BANNED by OnlyFans

Good lord, Bonnie Blue opened up about what Beavo was like in bed and I’m traumatised

Elma might have featured on Towie but sadly all I can see is Geordie Shore.

8. Casey O’Gorman

Casey’s Instagram is 80 per cent shirtless pictures and 20 per cent Tom Clare, but a simple monochromatic look never hurt anybody. I approve.

7. Kaz Crossley

Her outfits while travelling are almost always better than when she is at home, but I understand, why would you be wearing a ballgown to Pret to grab a croissant?

6. ​​Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu

Very Maura Higgins-esque, but the sequel is never as good as the first.

5. Scott Thomas

Scott Thomas dresses like someone’s ‘cool’ uncle, which makes sense because he is someone’s cool uncle.

4. Olivia Hawkins

I hate to admit it, but she always looks good.

3. Luca Bish

Luca would probably be number one but I can’t decide if he’s a really good dresser or just really attractive.

2. India Reynolds

Rarely misses and likes to mix it up, India could give even the most fashion-focused Islanders a run for their money.

1. Catherine Agbaje

Queen. Obsessed. No Notes.

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.  

Featured image credit: Luca Bish/Ekin-Su/India Reynolds