Ranking all the Love Island 2025 cast by who came out looking worse after Casa Amor

Ahh, Casa Amor. This year, the big mid season saga isn’t quite up there with the best of them when it comes to causing chaos, mess and destruction – but in many ways, this is more of a sign of how great and drama filled this season has been in its own right. Who needs Casa Amor when you get mess every night anyway? Nonetheless, Casa Amor for Love Island 2025 has come and gone with the drama of last night’s recoupling – so here’s who came out looking the best and the worst in a handy ranking.

The ones who came out best at the top, and the worst at the bottom.

17. Emma

Harry’s ex did what she needed to do and what we all wanted her to do: Dragged him to hell and back. Perfect. The icing on the cake being that she got a Conor shaped ride into the main villa. Smashed it, really.

16. Shakira

As usual, the villa GOAT handled herself like a pro. Annihilated Helena without even trying and got the man she rightfully deserved. Queen shit. Love her so, so, SO much.

15. Boris

Via ITV

Simply the sexiest man to ever go onto Love Island. My Slovenian king. Never have I been happier than to see him get into the villa. Wow. And on top of all the sexy, he’s witty and kind and mysterious too.

14. Yasmin and Jamie

Yasmin is a national treasure at this point and I am chuffed to pieces she’s found a fella who is equally as smug about how great a neck on he is. Deserved.

13. Lauren

Most Read

Lily Phillips shows grim aftermath of sleeping with 1,113 men in a day in horrid videos

Even MORE tweets from Helena before Love Island 2025 resurface, and they’re bad

A rundown of all the drama between Selena Gomez and Francia Raisa

Didn’t do much wrong or right, but did make faces so extreme when Emily was doing her speech about staying with Tommy so bait that she might as well have just stood up and said “don’t do it, Emily!” Don’t give it all away before they walk in, girl!

12. Cach

Happy he’s with Toni, since she is god to me and he seems great. Loved him calling out Harrison and I pray it gets beefy.

11. Conor

Love Conor but he was just doing anything. I keep looking at his recoupling track record and chuckling. Zero rhyme nor reason to it.

10. Ben and Andrada

Via ITV

Booting off the top 10 worst from the Love Island 2025 Casa Amor ranking with these two lumped together. Andrada seems nice enough albeit semi jarring, and Ben is utterly abysmal so. Maybe they’ll work out. I doubt it.

9. Ty

I like Ty a lot and I’m happy for Shakira but he hits into the worst section of this ranking simply because he actually entertained Helena. I cannot reward this behaviour.

8. Tommy and Lucy

Via ITV

They didn’t do anything wrong but the pair of them are going to come out looking dreadful in the eyes of the villa, and Emily will be the saint. It just doesn’t look great when Tommy has been gassed up for how loyal he is, but I don’t care really. Anyone who brings a Scouse diva into the main villa is a friend of mine!

7. Billykiss

Adore Billykiss immensely and we thank her to the end of time for amplifying Boris screen time – but I’m afraid she gets into the worse half of the Love Island 2025 Casa Amor ranking for that ABYSMAL kiss she had with Martin. It’s one of the worst ever to hit TV.

6. Giorgio

I feel bad ranking Giorgio so low here because he’s the nicest man in the entire villa. It was very respectful that he didn’t lead X Factor Yasmin on. But I do think it was kinda mean to not just recouple with her anyway and get X Factor Yasmin into the villa! Let her have a go!

5. Toni and Harrison

It pains me so much having my Toni in the top five worst when it comes to this ranking of Love Island 2025 Casa Amor behaviours, but these two are toxic as all hell. They recoupled to spite each other and clearly still have a thing for each other. Lauren and Cach feel like means to an end. Not fair on them!

4. Emily

Via ITV

Ahh. The crime of being… Very naive.

3. Meg

Didn’t look as bad as Dejon but just always handles herself horrifically. Why you beefing Shakira mid game?

2. Dejon

Two words: Movie. Night.

1. Harry and Helena

Via ITV

The fact that they remained loyal to each other was meant to have us all wowing but honestly the pair of them deserve each other. Good luck to them but I won’t be engaging or supporting.

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.