Relationship expert predicts who will win Love Island All Stars, and it’s unexpected

The Love Island All Stars 2025 finale is in sight, and the question on every viewer’s mind is which couple will be taking home the crown. Gemma Nice, an award-winning Sex and Relationships expert told Buzz Bingo her thoughts and observations on the final Love Island All Stars couples and gave her verdict on who should actually be winning based on compatibility. I’m shocked, to say the least! Here’s her verdict on all the hopeful couples.

Casey can’t be emotionally available with Gabby

via ITV

Gemma noted that Casey doesn’t have the “ability or capacity to have emotional availability,” which she noted was a “red flag.”

“He might not even know he has this, but this gets in the way of being emotional and having deep conversations. It means he also might not want to talk about serious or important things which crop up in relationships because he doesn’t know how to.”

She explained he’s been “building a barrier” between him and Gabby, and it’s essential for him to “do the inner work” before getting serious with her.

Ekin and Curtis are only going to find it harder to communicate on the outside

Most Read

Two Love Islanders have finally admitted they’re a couple after years of speculation

Guys! A FOURTH Islander has quit Love Island All Stars and this is so messy

Oh! This is the missing context to Elma and Ekin-Su’s heated dinner clash we all needed

via ITV

Gemma said Ekin and Curtis don’t seem like a strong couple at all when it comes to communication. “They skirt around the subject without actually saying what is on their mind,” she said. “They both have big personalities and yes in the villa, it’s all good as it’s not the real world but on the outside, I think they will have issues due to miscommunication and trying to compete for who is better at something.”

Harriett and Ronnie are in for a shock once the honeymoon phase is over

Anyone can see how quickly Ronnie switched up when Harriett walked into the villa, but that could be more of a red flag than a green one.

She did say there is “a lot of stigma” around people getting back with their exes. “There is a reason why they split up in the first place and if this reason isn’t rectified before getting back together, it can then come back up later on down the line in the relationship. With regards to Ronnie cheating on Harriett, there obviously was something astray in the relationship, their communication had broken down, and they maybe weren’t being honest with each other or not seeing each other as often as they may have liked, and this can then start to put a strain on the relationship. I see this time and time again where there isn’t enough communication and blame starts to happen. Also where people are working and not putting the effort into the relationship, cracks start to appear, and things change. Arguments start to happen, and blame is thrown around. They need to be open, honest, raw and real with their emotions.”

Luca and Grace’s love languages are perfect for each other

Surprisingly, Gemma thought Luca and Grace were “perfect” for each other.

They certainly do have a strong bond especially if there was temptation from Samie, but Luca still chose Grace. They can both see what they have although the real test will be on the outside but if they carry on with great communication, they will be fine.”

The final predictions

Overall, Gemma’s relationship expert verdict is that Luca and Grace should win Love Island All Stars.

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.