We’ve all gone off Elma, so who’s your favourite girl on Love Island All Stars?

When Love Island last did a poll about who the nation’s favourite All Stars girl is, Elma won. But that was, like, a small age ago, before she appears to have inexplicably decided that Ekin-Su and Curtis are the devil. So I think it’s time for a do-over. Elma needs humbling. So, who is your favourite of the Love Island: All Stars girls? Read through our very scientific justifications, then cast your vote below!

Catherine

So impressed she’s made it this far without screaming at everyone
(Image via ITV)

She had a rough start in the villa, so thank goodness she’s now happily coupled up with Omar. Catherine is an unproblematic queen who has caused no drama and managed to not antagonise any of her fellow Islanders. Impressive stuff.

Ekin-Su

So we’re all voting for Ekin-su to the win in the finale right? She’s been ostracized, talked down to, and picked on in the villa and I will not stand for it. I don’t appreciate how no one has stood up for that girl. She deserves the win and Elma can F off#loveislandallstars pic.twitter.com/KTrymsZrdf

— neds (@nedzdenz) February 13, 2025

Hey, she’s never boring. Maybe you’re like Elma and haven’t moved on from her kissing Curtis. Or the whole Danielle fingerbrushgate. But even if she is a liar and an actress, literally nothing interesting would happen in the villa without her.

Elma

Her fits are always on fire, tbh
(Image via ITV)

Er, well some people did like her at some point because a few weeks back she was publicly declared the most popular girl on Love Island: All Stars, then burst into tears as if she’d just won the lottery.

Gabby

I wonder how it must feel to be Gabby right now knowing she’s the only girl in Casey’s 3 season love island HISTORY that he’s actually had feelings for and wanted to meet his family 😭🥺🥺🥺 #LoveIslandAllStars pic.twitter.com/eiHrw65LtQ

— Scarlett Milne (@scarmilnex) February 9, 2025

Most Read

Guys! A FOURTH Islander has quit Love Island All Stars and this is so messy

Two Love Islanders have finally admitted they’re a couple after years of speculation

Doctor breaks down what is going on with Grace’s hair extensions on Love Island All Stars

The other Islanders all seem to love Gabby, because literally every time someone gets dumped they all heap praise on her and Casey and gush about how strong their connection is or whatever. Five out of eight of the reject Islanders think she and Casey will win. Plus, Gabby coped admirably when the producers shoved her in the villa with her ex.

Grace

I think Casey would vote for Grace
(Image via ITV)

Er, well she and Luca definitely seem to be getting close. She certainly excels at making duvet tents. Not so much at haircare.

Harriett

The strange spelling of her name is her parents’ fault, not hers, so we shouldn’t hold it against her too much x
(Image via ITV)

There is a severe risk that if you don’t vote for Harriett, she might tell you to shut your f*cking mouth and we don’t want that.

So, who’s your favourite Love Island: All Stars girl?

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.