Why are people boycotting oat milk? Here’s why the dairy alternative is under fire

Say it ain’t so


In an increasingly sustainable world, the move towards dairy alternatives is often recognised as a good thing. But like any new concept, there’s a level of opposition to the world of plant based milks.
It’s not unusual for dairy products to face criticism and opposition from environmentalist groups but the boycott of oat milk has proved that dairy alternatives aren’t immune to being cancelled either.
This surge in veganism has boosted the market for dairy alternatives, making oat milk a go-to for many, and has even grown popular with many who aren’t dairy free. Since it’s boost in popularity, the oat product was once praised as being the healthier, environmentally friendly answer to cow’s milk. But in recent years, people’s opinions on oat milk have taken a bit of a u-turn, with some even going so far as to boycott it.

Many former plant based milk fans are once again looking for an alternative to their milk alternative, ironically driven by the same ethical and health concerns that originally led them to choose drinking it in the first place.

So from fads to facts, let’s break down the reasons behind the oat milk boycott.

There are reported environmental concerns about its production

Although oat milk can be seen as a more sustainable choice over cows milk or other plant based milks, there’s an argument that oat farming still requires significant water resources. Its production still involves processes which contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, including transportation of oats, production of oat milk in factories, and the packaging. Some people feel that this is often overlooked and not discussed enough when oat milk is advertised as a sustainable choice.

Some brands like Oatly have significantly improved their ecological footprints by reducing the amount of packaging used, and the amount of emmissions used in production. Oatly also outlined how it sourced 100 per cent renewable electricity for all Oatly operated factories.

Whilst others claim they were led to believe oat milk was a healthy alternative

Wellness is a hot topic right now and everyone seems to be doing Hyrox, running half marathons or have switched up part of their diet in an effort to consume a “cleaner” diet.

So it’s easy to associate vegan and dairy free options with healthy eating, with most veggie influencers being pioneers of wellness and health, and animal product alternatives often being advertised as the better option. However, a lot of people are moving away from consuming oat milk after claiming they were almost tricked into believing it was a wellness product.

That’s because researchers have found that the nutritional content of most milk alternatives, including our beloved oat milk, doesn’t measure up to cow’s milk. Of course, that might be obvious to some of us, but the health benefits of oat milk aren’t necessarily its biggest benefits. That is often overlooked by consumers and boycotters alike.

One brand, Oatly, received investment from a company which supports Donald Trump

The popular oat milk brand Oatly received a $200 million investment from from Blackstone, an alternative investment management company, and a group of other high profile investors.

But Blackstone’s CEO previously donated $3.7million to Donald Trump’s 2020 campaign for reelection. And people had stuff to say about this.

The ‘It’s Like Milk But Made For Humans’ campaign 

Back in 2023, the National Dairy Council in Ireland complained about an advertising campaign Oatly ran, where it used the term “It’s Like Milk But Made For Humans”.

Believing the brand shouldn’t be allowed to say that, a ruling was made with the conclusion that the ASAI agreed with Oatly on two of the three issues raised.

Oatly said at the time: “The National Dairy Council is concerned that our ad ‘It’s Like Milk But Made for Humans’ has the potential to mislead shoppers.

“Shoppers are entitled to choice and they don’t owe the dairy industry a default position in their lives. We are therefore reassured the ASAI agree with us on two of the three issues raised. Oat drink can of course be used for the same purpose as cow’s milk and dairy.”

Oatly and Blackstone have been contacted for comment. 

For all the latest news and drama, drops and memes, like The Tab on Facebook

More on: Oat Milk Trends Viral