An expert shares if Luca should choose Grace or Samie on All Stars, and the answer is a shock

Right now on Love Island All Stars, the biggest drama is the triangle that’s formed between Luca, Grace and Samie. Previously, Luca and Grace had been cracking on and looked solid. But then bombshell Samie showed up, Luca kissed her in a challenge, and the public devilishly coupled Luca and Samie up. It really has been a mess.

Since all of this, the nation has been divided. Should Luca know where his bread is buttered and stick with Grace? Or would he be a fool for not giving Samie a chance? Speaking exclusively to The Tab, an expert has had their say on what he should do.

Speaking on behalf of FruitySlots.com, relationship and dating coach Jacob Lucas said Luca needs to give Samie a chance. Divisive! He said Luca is now “walking on eggshells” with Grace, and clearly has “an attraction towards Samie.”

via ITV

“After the public chose him and Samie to be a new couple, Luca needs to explore his options and give Samie a chance,” Jacob explained to The Tab. “We should see Luca and Samie interact a bit more now they’re coupled up. Before Samie came in, Luca did seem pretty closed off to talk to other people other than Grace. He was enjoying his time with her and they seemed pretty tight. So, I do think Grace did bring out a good side in him before Samie came in.

Most Read

People have worked out the ‘real reason’ so many Islanders are quitting All Stars

Reporters issue apology after backlash following ‘rude’ Grammys interview with Babyface

These six Russell Group unis are officially among the most overcrowded in the world

“However, Luca has changed now. In terms of who he is more comfortable with, you can tell Luca is on edge after kissing Samie in the challenge. He’s walking on eggshells around Grace and he’s scared he’s going to say or do the wrong thing. When he was chilling with Samie on the sunbeds, he was awkward – but I think that’s down to the situation and being afraid of doing something wrong.”

Luca and Grace’s relationship ‘can’t return to how it was’

via ITV

Breaking down more of how he knows this, Jacob said Luca’s body language has given away a lot about how he feels now. Jacob said: “When Luca was with Grace before Samie walked in, Luca’s body language was open and positive. They were kissing, touching a lot and just reassuring each other.

“But now that Samie has come in, Luca is more awkward around both Grace and Samie. He isn’t getting as close to Grace as he was before. We’re seeing this because it’s clear Luca does have an emotional response and an attraction towards Samie. If he didn’t have any feelings towards Samie, we wouldn’t have seen him become awkward, he would have been nonchalant and he wouldn’t care that she was even in the villa.”

He noted that since Samie’s arrival, Luca’s relationship with Grace has become “fractured” and can’t return to how it was before. Ouch!

“There’s a lack of trust now and I think if he keeps going with Grace, he will continue to be walking on eggshells around her. I don’t think it can return to how it initially was,” Jacob said.

“When the trust is gone, it’s gone. I think they’re a few steps away from their relationship turning slightly sour. To stop that from happening, they need to make things work healthily. Luca will need to be on his best behaviour. He needs to reassure Grace a lot. She’s feeling hurt and insecure. He needs to convince her that he’s putting her first. If he can’t do that, the relationship will need to come to an end.”

Well, that’s that one then!

For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.