Twitter decided who should be crowned sexiest man alive 2024, and it’s not Benny Blanco

This is Shawn Mendes erasure

1 day ago

People magazine usually gets its sexiest man alive award right every year – we’ve had Patrick Dempsey, Chris Evans and Paul Rudd most recently. This year, people are freaking out that Benny Blanco made the 2024 list. While the real winner has yet to be announced, people on Twitter are already making up their own minds about who the sexiest man alive 2024 award should actually go to.

the rage and confusion that just went through my body when i thought benny blanco was being announced sexiest man alive… i’m gonna need a minute pic.twitter.com/JRlwBP8YNd

— shelby jo ⛧ (she/her) (@pastureangel) November 11, 2024

Benny Blanco has not been crowned, but we’ve had a week of shocking revelations such as the U.S. election and the Grammys snubs, so we can forgive people for being a bit jumpy about it. Here’s who Twitter has decided should actually be the winner of the sexiest man alive 2024 competition. Find out if you agree, and even have your own say at the end!

Jensen Ackles

the fuck you mean benny blanco made it on the people’s sexiest man alive issue and jensen ackles didn’t………… pic.twitter.com/JaGrkU6yio

— alexa (@deanscinema) November 11, 2024

An underrated hottie. Dean Winchester!!

Johnathan Bailey

I feel like Jonathan Bailey makes the most sense to be named People's Sexiest Man Alive tomorrow, right? pic.twitter.com/62HadQJsqn

— Jarett Wieselman (@JarettSays) November 11, 2024

Ding ding ding! Johnathan Bailey is the sexiest man alive EVERY year.

Manny Jacinto

the real sexiest man alive is manny jacinto
pic.twitter.com/3D5vTAF5qD

— rie (@huntzberqer) November 12, 2024

Just found my new favourite man of the month. Hi Manny Jacinto!

Joe Jonas

joe jonas is my top sexiest man alive 2024 and onwards btw pic.twitter.com/RDHOKdfr6N

— kristal (@tmylmjonas) November 11, 2024

A life long classic. Joe Jonas will never not be my crush, even if he did break up with Taylor Swift in a 27 second phone call.

Keith Powers

Benny Blanco being Peoples "Sexiest Man Alive" when Keith Powers is alive and well is certainly a choice pic.twitter.com/v1XWH1kO8y

— bless (@blessthebeautyy) November 12, 2024

Keith Powers was SNUBBED. End of story!

Glen Powell

if glen powell wins sexiest man alive 2024 ill edit his workout videos to a diabolical audio, if glen powel loses sexiest man alive 2024 ill edit his workout videos to a diabolical audio its a win win (HE BETTER FUCKING WIN) #glenpowell

— katie 🌪 FREE PALESTINE🇵🇸 (@clickerkatie) November 12, 2024

Glen Powell is an obvious candidate who definitely deserves the win. He knew what he was doing in Anyone But You!

Josh Hartnett

me going to sleep knowing i’ll wake up to see josh hartnett named as people’s sexiest man alive pic.twitter.com/6D4xmKEJK1

— alli (@allinicolee5) November 12, 2024

I always forget about Josh Hartnett until I see him in a film and fall in love with him all over again. Where is his sexiest man alive award?!

Jeremy Renner

So now people are arguing over sexiest man alive? It's clearly the man who fought to live. Jeremy Renner. pic.twitter.com/TQDOT2fJCy

— Sarah Jane 🦄 (@pinktastic615) November 11, 2024

I’m sure most Marvel fans would agree with this one. Hawkeye is sexy!

Dev Patel

Who? No. No, guys, it's Dev Patel. Dev Patel is objectively the sexiest man alive. https://t.co/txoUJwBv1U pic.twitter.com/IBHfFGMNSV

— King is revising 💙✨ (@king_reinhardt) November 11, 2024