The verdict’s in: These are officially the worst ever book to screen adaptations

For very obvious reasons, we are constantly swarmed by popular book to screen adaptations – and these either end up being a huge success critically and / or commercially or an utterly panned flop. When adaptations of popular books come to the screen they bring with them huge pressure of audience expectations. Who has the production cast in roles fans have been dying to see and are they who people imagined or wanted? How faithful has the adaptation been? All these factors can create success or disaster, and now we have some analysed data that has rounded up the worst ever book to screen adaptations.

Book enthusiasts at Aura Print analysed the differences between the GoodReads book score and the IMDb score of the screen adaptation to see those with the biggest percentage difference – giving us a top 10 rundown of the worst book to screen adaptations ever. Buckle up.

10. Where The Crawdads Sing

The big screen adaptation of Where The Crawdads Sing had a lot of hype – mostly because of its big casting of Daisy Edgar Jones and a huge Taylor Swift original song on the soundtrack. However, despite decent commercial success – the film has a disparaging score between its decent GoodReads 4.38/5 and its IMDb 7.2. This is a 21.7 per cent difference.

9. The Perfect Couple

Via Netflix

Most Read

Lacey reveals why her homestay with Nathan wasn’t shown during MAFS UK

Guys, two MAFS UK 2024 cast members just confirmed their couple swap since the show!

Um guys, Alex and Holly have got back together since they quit MAFS UK 2024?!

Nicole Kidman had huge viewership success with this year’s The Perfect Couple – everyone binged it in a weekend. However the whodunnit didn’t go down as well on screen as it did in the book. GoodReads gives Elin Hilderbrand’s book a 3.98 – but the show has an IMDb score of 6.5. This gives the versions a difference of 22.5 per cent.

8. Elvis and Me

Elvis and Me was adapted to the 2024 Sofia Coppola movie Priscilla, which saw Priscilla Presley act as producer. Honestly, I loved this film and Cailee Spaeny and Jacob Elordi were great. To be fair, though, I never read the book. Elvis and Me has a GoodReads of 4.0 and Priscilla has an IMDb score of 6.5 – giving them a 23.1 per cent difference.

7. Damsel

You know an IMDb score hates to see Millie Bobby Brown coming – has she ever been in a film that has gone down well? This Netflix adaptation of Damsel has a contrasting percentage of 24.6, with a GoodReads 3.8 and an IMDb 6.8.

6. The Boys in the Boat

Remember seeing the trailer for this and thinking: Who’s arsed? Apparently, no one. GoodReads score of 4.39 out of 5 – very high – but a mid IMDb of 7. Percentage gap of 25.4 – moving on.

5. The Colour Purple

A horrendous stat that this is even in the list, let alone top five worst book to screen adaptations. Let’s be serious! The book is amazing and the film is great – but alas the great GoodReads score of 4.27 has a 25.6 per cent difference to its IMDb rating of 6.8.

4. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

Holly Jackson’s book has a hefty GoodReads score of 4.38 – but this year’s TV adaptation did not stick the landing, with a much lower 6.8 score on IMDb. That 26.8 per cent difference has got it in fourth.

3. It Ends With Us

Here we go – the big chaos and controversy laden disaster of the year thanks to Blake Lively. The Coleen Hoover book was hugely popular and yet the film was a car crash for many, many reasons. The two versions have a 27.4 per cent difference in quality, as per a GoodReads of 4.14 VS an IMDb of 6.5.

2. The Changeling

The worst thing here is this version of The Changeling is actually good, but the IMDb score is shocking – with the 2023 series getting a 5.8 compared to a decent GoodReads. Refuse to believe this is worse than It Ends With Us!

1. Uglies

And here we are: The worst book to screen adaptation of all adaptations. This year’s panned Uglies on Netflix was a disaster – and the ratings percentage different says it all. Hold your breath – there is a 63.8 per cent difference!!! Wild. The GoodReads has a 3.85 in contrast to a dismal IMDb of 4.7.