
Shane Beatty will only keep around $150k of his $246k Traitors: New Blood prize after tax
That's a big cut
The Traitors: New Blood winner Shane Beatty walked away with $246,300, but he won’t get to keep all of it. The Staten Island ironworker was recruited as a Traitor late in the game and ended up taking the whole prize pot for himself in the final. As with any big US game show win, a large chunk of the money goes straight to the taxman, and Shane already knows it. Here’s roughly how much he could lose, and how much he’ll actually take home.
In the US, game show winnings aren’t a tax-free windfall. They’re treated as ordinary income, the same as a salary, and they’re added on top of whatever you earn in your day job that year.
That matters, because the US taxes income in brackets. The more you earn, the higher the rate on each extra dollar. For 2026, a single person pays 22 per cent on income between $50,401 and $105,700, then 24 per cent up to $201,775, with 32 per cent and 35 per cent above that. A six-figure prize on top of a welder’s salary pushes most of the money into those higher brackets.
Then there’s where Shane lives. Because he’s from Staten Island, he isn’t just paying federal tax. He’s also paying New York State income tax and New York City income tax, as Staten Island is one of the city’s five boroughs. Together, those add roughly another 10%.
Put it all together and Shane could lose somewhere around $90,000 to $100,000 of his winnings, leaving him with roughly $145,000 to $155,000. The exact figure depends on his salary and deductions, so it could land a little either side.
Luckily, he’s well aware. Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, Shane said the first thing he’s doing with the money is putting “at least 100K in a separate bank account just so I can have it ready for Uncle Sam.”
The full pot was also never quite $250,000. The New Blood prize pot was worth up to that amount, and the group’s results in missions over the season left the final total at $246,300.
What’s left is going mostly into savings. Shane said he “grew out of all the materialistic stuff,” and the plan is to pay for his wedding, help his mum get a better car, replace his water heater and maybe take one trip to Hawaii or Tokyo.
“I’d rather have some money in the savings, a little nest egg, than walking around looking like I got money,” he said. Honestly, the most financially responsible Traitor of all time.
For all the latest reality TV cast member news, scandals, gossip and updates – like Reality Shrine on Facebook
