
‘I am not a judgmental person’: Mormon Wives: Orange County’s McCall claps back at criticism
'That couldn’t be further from who I am'
McCall is setting the record straight after a rocky first season of the new Secret Lives of Mormon Wives spinoff on Hulu, and Bobbi Althoff is right behind her. McCall spent much of the series clashing with the other girls, and it got worse when she brought her sister, OG MomTok member Mayci Neeley, into the drama. Now she says viewers got the wrong idea about her. Bobbi, who started the show as one of her biggest sceptics, is backing her up.
McCall’s main point is that she isn’t the judgmental one. “I feel like in general, I am not a judgmental person,” she told Decider. She said some of the girls assumed her traditional values meant she disapproved of how they lived. In fact, she grew up in California, where hardly any of her friends were LDS. “The majority of my friends are not members of church and don’t live the same life as me. I’m okay with that,” she said. “I love everyone’s differences and as long as we’re all respectful to each other, that’s all that matters.”
She also defended herself over the Palm Springs dinner where it all kicked off. That night she clashed with Avery Woods and Bobbi over whether what she meant mattered more than how her actions landed. Part of the row was about her reading comments left under posts about the cast. McCall claimed viewers didn’t see the whole thing. “A lot of it is like cut out and it’s taken out of context, so it’s kind of hard to really see everything,” she said.
After the dinner she texted Mayci in tears. McCall insisted she wasn’t trying to start anything. “Truthfully, the text message just happened so organically,” she said. The sisters were already chatting about how the cast had reacted to a video Mayci posted when the show was announced. In it, Mayci suggested some castmates were only there for clout. McCall said she reached out because she “felt really alone” and thought someone at the table might stick up for her. She also explained why Mayci came out swinging: “When I told her I was crying, that’s when she freaked out because I honestly don’t cry very often.”
This is where Bobbi steps in. She admitted she had McCall all wrong at the start, especially after McCall criticised her comedy set. “I thought she was so mean when I didn’t know her,” Bobbi told Elite Daily. “I judged her early on and had my guard up because I thought she thought I was weird. I was projecting my insecurities on her.”
Bobbi also agreed with McCall that the edit left things out. She said their turnaround looks sudden on screen because the moments where they bonded never made it to air. Those included a trip to an escape room, games of tennis, and Bobbi modelling for McCall’s jewellery line. McCall said she felt comfortable with Bobbi “right away, even though we had our tiff.”
Now Bobbi wants to make sure nobody writes McCall off the way she did. “After getting to know McCall and then seeing how she comes off on the show, I’ve been thinking of how I can make her look better,” she said. “I’m trying to help with McCall’s redemption arc.”
She also defended her on her Instagram story, writing: “I’m going to need all you people to stop bullying McCall. It’s really out of control. I understand she made some mistakes, but your response to calling her a mean girl is being mean? It’s not necessary.
“People make mistakes. People learn from them, and people grow. Imagine having your lowest, most vulnerable moments out there for everyone to see. Just be patient and kind and have grace because we are all human. Dogpiling on anyone is so mean and unnecessary.”
McCall also reflected on Instagram, sharing: “Looking back, the confrontation early on really came from us not knowing each other yet and not fully trusting one another. My light-hearted personality got misunderstood as judgmental, and that couldn’t be further from who I am. I’m not a judgmental person, and I stayed genuine to myself every step of the way.
“After watching the whole show through, I wish I had been closer to the girls from the very beginning so they would’ve felt safer and more comfortable with me. The more I see, the more empathy and love I feel for my cast-mates.”
For all the latest reality TV cast member news, scandals, gossip and updates – like Reality Shrine on Facebook.
