*Warning: Spoilers ahead for Yellowjackets season 4 episode 1* The end of the Yellowjackets season 4 premiere takes us back to the moment Natalie (Sophie Thatcher) heads to the mountains and uses the SAT phone to communicate with the outside world. As she runs back to share the news with the rest of the team, she stops dead in her tracks. “What the f**k,” she says. Although we don’t get to see what has left her so horrified, there’s a pretty convincing explanation. But before we get into it, let’s rewind. The fourth and final chapter of the horror series kicks off with something we’ve been wanting to know since season 1: what happened to the Yellowjackets team when they were rescued? As you can probably imagine, returning to civilisation isn’t exactly straightforward when you’ve spent the best part of two years hunting and eating your pals. And after being taken to hospital and reunited with their families, it doesn’t take long before the awkward questions begin. Credit: Paramount+ They’ve got their story prepared (notably, there’s no mention of wilderness rituals or cannibalism) but investigator Donald Kundla (Alessandro Juliani) isn’t buying it. As the girls learn, it wasn’t Nat’s message that saved them – it was a distress signal from the scientists from season 3. Remember Hannah (Ashley Sutton), Edwin (Nelson Franklin) and Kodiak (Joel McHale)? Well, to Kundla and his team, they’re still missing, and they want to get to the bottom of it. But they don’t have much luck getting answers. When they pull in Lottie (Courtney Eaton) and her parents for questioning, she starts screaming “No” over and over again. Similarly, after doctors find evidence of Shauna (Sophie Nélisse) having a baby, they ask her about it but she shuts down. Then there’s Mari’s (Alexa Barajas) mother, who is devastated to learn her daughter didn’t survive. The girls look understandably uncomfortable. If you recall, the season 3 finale finally revealed that Mari was the mysterious ‘Pit Girl’ from the very first episode. She’d drawn the Queen of Hearts during one of the group’s ritual hunts, and was subsequently killed and eaten by her teammates. Shortly after, they were rescued. Credit: Paramount+ Oh, and things aren’t exactly going swimmingly in the present day either. Season 3 saw adult Shauna (Melanie Lynskey) receive a mysterious DAT tape containing a recording from the wilderness – including evidence of the girls’ crimes. It turned out the tape had been sent by Melissa (Hilary Swank), who everyone thought had died years ago. Surprise! She’d actually faked her death and started a new life with Alex (Jaylee Hamidi), who just so happens to be the daughter of Hannah. Shauna tracked Melissa down, and things got rather ugly. Shauna attacked Melissa, who subsequently tried to kill the others by filling her house with carbon monoxide. Van (Lauren Ambrose) managed to save everyone, only for Melissa to stab her to death. A devastated Tai (Tawny Cypress) later cut out and ate Van’s heart. Yep, really. Credit: Paramount+ Now, in Yellowjackets season 4, Tai and Misty (Christina Ricci) are convinced Shauna could turn on them next. Their plan? To kill her first and make it look like a suicide. And if that weren’t chaotic enough, the last we see of the present timeline in season 4 episode 1 is Melissa and Alex moving in next door to Shauna. That’s not sus at all. Finally, we get to the scene of Natalie being left horrified by… something. What Natalie may have witnessed in the Yellowjackets season 4 premiere Credit: Paramount+ Given Natalie wasn’t present to see what went down with Mari, the leading theory is that she arrives back at camp to see Mari’s head on a spike – or something equally gruesome. And considering what happened in season 3, it’s not exactly a wild suggestion. If you recall, Akilah (Nia Sondaya) poisoned the animals at the behest of Lottie so that they could convince the rest of the team to hold another hunt. The plan was successful… kind of. Tai (Jasmin Savoy Brown) and Van (Liv Hewson) tried to rig the card draw so Hannah would be chosen, but Shauna caught on and changed the order. Unfortunately for Mari, she ended up drawing the Queen of Hearts instead. Shauna placed Jackie’s necklace around her neck, and Mari was given a head start before the others chased her into the woods. In a desperate attempt to throw them off, Mari stripped off her clothes and shoes, leaving her in the nightgown we saw the Pit Girl wearing all the way back in season 1. She then fell into a concealed pit filled with sharpened wooden stakes, which impaled and killed her. And things only got worse from there. The girls dragged Mari’s naked body back to camp before butchering her for their feast. Shauna presided over the whole thing while wearing the Antler Queen costume. She’d even decorated her outfit with locks of Mari’s hair. Credit: Paramount+ But here’s the important part: Natalie didn’t see any of this. She’d used the hunt as a distraction to escape with the repaired satellite phone, swapping clothes with Hannah so nobody would notice she was gone. We’ve seen the Yellowjackets do some pretty horrifying things to their victims before. Remember Javi? Back in season 2, he fell through the ice during a hunt originally intended for Natalie. Rather than save him, the girls let him drown, before Shauna butchered his body and the group ate him. And then there’s Jackie, whose frozen corpse was accidentally cooked when snow fell onto her funeral pyre. The starving girls subsequently devoured her remains. So it’s hardly beyond the realms of possibility that something equally disturbing happened to Mari’s body after the feast. Could the girls have displayed her severed head as some sort of trophy? Or was Natalie simply horrified at the aftermath of their feast? This is certainly the theory going round after the season 4 premiere. Over on Reddit, one person wrote, “Natalie definitely found Mari’s head or body in the end… or something Akilah-cave related.” Another theorised that she’s “seeing Mari’s head or part of her remains”, adding, “she seemed almost disgusted? And genuinely shocked.” Credit: Paramount+ However, there’s another theory doing the rounds. As some viewers have pointed out, Natalie knew a hunt was happening. So perhaps she returned to find something else entirely: Shauna getting the absolute crap beaten out of her. And there’s actually a pretty big clue supporting this one. Remember how Shauna has a black eye and other facial injuries in the premiere’s rescue scenes? Well, we still don’t know how she got them. The season 4 trailer also shows Shauna looking bloodied and bruised in the pit that killed Mari. Maybe the girls turned on her as she’s gone mad with power and insists on staying in the wilderness. As said by one viewer, “Also really curious to see what Natalie saw when she came back. I don’t think it’s Mari as Natalie knew there was a hunt and the chance someone died was high. I assume the rest of the team already beat up Shauna and that’s what she saw.” Another commented, “I have to assume that Natalie ran into a group beatdown of Shauna and that’s why she reacted how she did – she must have known that there was a high chance she was coming back to Mari’s remains, so I doubt she would be so confused at seeing her body… unless it was a response to her hair being cut off?” Whatever turns out to be the case, there’s not long to wait. Yellowjackets season 4 episode 2 lands on Paramount+ on Friday, November 27. For all the latest film and TV updates and hot takes, like our Facebook page. Featured image credit: Paramount+ Post navigation Next storyPrevious story