Sara Boustany has become one of the most talked-about stars thanks to Netflix’s The Body, but what you might not know is that she’s been on our screens for years. And in one of her earlier roles, she’s almost unrecognisable. The 23-year-old actress is among the highly talented The Body cast, playing Anya Butler’s (Kristina Bogic) best friend Elise Zakaria. Yes, Elise can be a bit of a mean girl at times, but she’s going through things herself – not least being in love with Anya in an era where being gay wasn’t widely accepted. And throughout the chaos of the Netflix series, she’s the only person to see through all of the bullsh*t that unfolds after fellow student Grace (Sofia Wylie) collapses. Sara does an excellent job at portraying the many layers to her character. With her striking looks and standout performance, it’s hardly surprising that Sara has caught viewers’ attention. But anyone going back through her earlier acting credits might be in for a surprise, because she looks so different in one of her first TV appearances. There’s a simple reason Sara Boustany looks so different in her first big TV role Sara played a character named Miranda in the Hulu comedy series Pen15. A fan of The Body went through the show to find her character, sharing both a picture and a clip. It’s easier to see Elise in the video, but the photo genuinely had me doing a double take: اوميقاد شوفو وش لقيت سارا بمسلسل PEN15 وشجابها فيه!!! اميره تهبل #thebody pic.twitter.com/6oEMRW6AsG — نِيل (@icanerase) November 16, 2026 There’s a very obvious reason she looks so different. Pen15 dropped in 2019, meaning she would’ve only been around 15 or 16 at the time. Plus, she’s playing a character in middle school and the hair, makeup and clothes are totally different. While The Body is set in 2004, the cast are playing high schoolers. Pen15, on the other hand, is set in 2000 and the characters are in middle school. Sara plays one of the “cool girls” who invites main characters Maya (Maya Erskine) and Anna (Anna Konkle) over for a sleepover in episode 2. You can check out more stills from the show below: Credit: Hulu Credit: Hulu Credit: Hulu Credit: Hulu As said, Sara was still a teenager when PEN15 came out, so it’s hardly surprising she looks different now. It’s also worth pointing out that while The Body makes several references to Elise having had a nose job, that’s part of her character’s storyline, and not a claim about the actress herself. And it’s not just her old acting roles that have resurfaced amid the Netflix show’s success. Over on Reddit, someone claiming to have a rather unexpected connection to Sara’s family shared a throwback picture of the actress from her high school days. Credit: Reddit/Mundane-Size6714/Facebook “I’m randomly friends with her grandma on Facebook, no idea how,” they wrote alongside the photo. Sara Boustany nearly gave up acting before landing The Body Although Sara has been acting since her teens, The Body came up at an important crossroads in her career. Credit: Netflix As she revealed in an interview with Entertainment Weekly, “It was when I was dropping everything in my life and taking acting really seriously and being like, ‘If I don’t book a job in six months, it’s over.’” Sara even made a vision board ahead of the audition, adding, “There was a section for casting directors, and Jennifer Venditti’s face is right in the middle of it. During my audition, I was like, ‘You’re under my bed right now.’” Thankfully, it paid off – but maybe not in the way she expected. In a separate interview with Netflix’s Tudum, Sara revealed that she’d originally auditioned for the role of Anya. Credit: Netflix “Jennifer called and said, ‘They think you’re Elise, we’re going to have a callback,’ and she gave me some pointers,” she explained. At this point, Sara realised she was “100 percent” Elise. “I think Elise’s character and arc are for the people who’ve experienced an unrequited love with someone who isn’t ready to take on a journey of self acceptance and discovery, which is sadly common in queer relationships,” she continued. “I hope that Elise makes people feel less alone in that experience.” Quite the journey from playing Miranda in Pen15, really. For all the latest film and TV updates and hot takes, like our Facebook page. Featured image credit: Netflix/Hulu Post navigation Next storyPrevious story