The new Harry Potter series is getting utterly dragged again after HBO shared a new clip featuring additional scenes that aren’t in the book, so here’s what was changed. HBO recently shared a scene showing Harry Potter‘s first feast in the Great Hall, with Dominic McLaughlin as Harry and John Lithgow as Dumbledore. While the scene looks familiar to anyone who has watched the original films, there are actually a couple of details that weren’t in the book. Since the first trailer came out, the show has received massive backlash for numerous reasons. Now, the new clip has also attracted loads of criticism. One viewer called it “absolute slop that should not exist”, while another wrote, “The best way to describe the new Harry Potter series is that they all look like they’re fully aware that they’re in a Harry Potter series.” A third person wrote, “Why’s it filmed like an SNL skit?” So, what exactly has HBO changed from the original story, and why are people dragging the new Harry Potter clip? 1. The students chant Dumbledore’s name Credit: HBO One of the biggest changes from the first book comes right at the start of the scene. In the new clip, as Dumbledore makes his entrance, the Hogwarts students start chanting his name. This never happened in the original book or the 2001 film. Yes, the students clap and cheer as he enters in the book, but they don’t chant his name like they’re at a rally. 2. McGonagall tells Dumbledore that Harry looks like his father Credit: HBO There’s another scene at the professors’ table that wasn’t taken directly from the book. In the clip, Janet McTeer’s Professor McGonagall tells Dumbledore that Harry resembles his father, James Potter. The original book doesn’t include this exchange during the feast. It’s mentioned quite a lot throughout the books and films that Harry looks like James, but this particular conversation never happens. Also, the books are told from Harry’s perspective, and he’s initially a little in awe of, and intimidated by, both professors. So, he technically doesn’t know this conversation is happening. 3. Harry and Ron joke about Dumbledore Credit: HBO The clip also includes a small exchange between Harry and Ron about whether Dumbledore is “a bit mad”. Now, Harry does make a comment about Dumbledore being a bit mad, but not to Ron and not after Dumbledore’s arrival at the feast. Instead, he asks Percy, one of Ron’s older brothers, after Dumbledore delivers his rather peculiar “Nitwit! Blubber! Oddment! Tweak!” speech. The original placement would arguably have made much more sense, but oh well. 4. The Great Hall is supposed to be lit by candles Credit: HBO Among the many other issues people have raised about how the show looks so far, one detail in the new clip is a bit off-putting. In the book, and even in the first film, the Great Hall is lit by thousands of floating candles suspended in mid-air. But in the new HBO clip, there appear to be lamps on the tables instead. It’s a hugely unnecessary change, especially when the floating candles are such an iconic part of Hogwarts. Anyway, the series is expected to premiere on 25 December 2026. And with more footage likely to be released before the premiere, HBO still has a lot to prove to viewers who aren’t convinced by what they’ve seen so far. For all the latest film and TV updates and hot takes, like our Facebook page. Post navigation Next story